Reviews for NY Pie in Santa Rosa, CA
Love the buffalo mild wings and the knots. The pizza was so good, we didn?t even talk in between bites. We drive almost 2 hours... to come eat here and it hasn?t disappointed. The owner is so nice! He recommended things on the menu and they were delicious! Wewill be coming back for when we want NY style pizza! Definitely recommend! Read more
??????NEVER COME HERE THIS IS YOUR WARNING ?????? My husband and I went in 11/10/22. When we got there it wasn?t busy in the... establishment at all. We got a young kid as our server, who kept having to put his pants up every time he walked even though hehad a belt on his pants. The pizza was okay flavor is decent. The one thing I saw was the parmesan cheese in the containers onour table had mold. I grabbed another one from a different table and that one too had mold. I went to the manger and told himquietly since there were a lot more people there at the time eating pizza about there issue. He went up to our server and showedhim and our server just acknowledged it but didn?t do anything about it. He later came and asked if we wanted any more cheesewhich I refused after seening mold. His excuse was the server from the previous night left them out when they should havebrought them into a walk in fridge which is a lie. Mold does not accumulate in one night. Who knows how long the cheese wasthere and how many people have gotten sick. I WILL NEVER GO THERE AGAIN. Read more
Just went here for dinner and the garlic knots were incredible. I kept dipping the knots in the garlic butter and it made them... so good. The pizza is good but the crust could be thicker and more sauce then it would of been a home run. My little salad wasgood but had too many olives. I would go back but try a different pizza Read more
Wouldn't even give them 1 star. The worst service I've ever had. Been there twice within the past year. Thought I'd give it... another try this past Friday night to see if it has improved service wise. It's only gotten worse. Went there months ago & theyforgot to give my salad with my order. Friday night my self & my neighbor went. The pizza was cold. They didn't give us anystraws or silverware. I had to get up 3 times & ask for things. My, neighbor orders wings. They sat up on the food line foratleast 10. I had to get up & ask for them. They were like warm. The kid at the counter insisted they were steaming hot. No,they were steaming hot for the 10 minutes they sat up on the food line. My work will not tolerate this kinda poor service. Ifood run 2 days a week at my job & I'm also a bartender. My work would not tolerate this kinda poor service. We, served a 100plates in 3 hrs Thursday night & everyone was happy not 1 complaint. And, that bartender of yours is a creep. He was talkingabout feeling up some girl in the restaurant & bragging to some customers about how he couldn't get in trouble because he wasoff the clock. You, guys need to clean house & hire a new crew! Read more
Jesse the Manager does a great job running the restaurant, from taking orders making pizzas and pouring pints by the dozen. All... while keeping the dinning room spotless. Hand's down best pizza ever. And over dozen local craft brewskis. ???? Read more
Ordered a BYO pizza from their website and was very impressed with both the ease and detail of their ordering system. Very... accurate and staff followed the order perfectly. Pizza was massive and price was very reasonable for such a huge pie, 2 1/2slices filled me up for dinner. Crust was AMAZING. Selected the option to have the pizza "well done", the crust was so crunchyand delicious. Tons of cheese, sauce was tasty and not overwhelming (I always go easy on the red sauce). Super satisfied andwishing I didn't live an hour away from this location. Will make sure to visit whenever I am up in Santa Rosa! Read more
Yummy! Love that you can buy pizza by the slice ???? Staff is friendly. Ranch is yummy (I am picky about my ranch). And they're... open until 3 AM ???? Read more
Used to patron this and Mombos fairly often as back in the day before covid these two pizza shops made the best NY slices. Went... in about a couple weeks ago and ordered a fresh pie, as the slice pizzas were cold and looked like they?ve sat out all daybehind that glass. Ordered wings too. Pizza was tasteless and dry and the wings were the same. Don?t know where it ended upgoing down hill and how you can mess up a pizza like this, but unfortunately it wasn?t the first time it has happened to mehere. Most likely the last time though. Both pizza shops, here and Mombos are way overpriced and you could get a better pizza inyour frozen foods department at your local grocery. Or learn to make your own pizza. Sorry. Read more