Reviews for Love Boat Ice Cream in Sanibel, FL

A very nice Ice Cream Shop, has tons of Flavors, and even 3 Low Fat Sugar Free Options! I had the Smores Ice Cream and my wife... had the Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream. I tried both and while of course both were very different, they were both delicious! Agem of a Mom & Pop Ice Cream Place on Sanibel, give it a try when you are on the Island! Read more

Amazing ice cream and they give you sooooo much for the price!! My 7 year old Granddaughter couldn't finish the kids size and... she's an ice cream fanatic. Lol Highly recommend!! Read more

By FAR the best ice cream we have ever had!! There is nothing that even compares. There has to be close to 50 flavors to choose... from, and it?s so hard to decide, because everything this far has been amazing and we usually want the same thing next time -ha! Highly, highly recommend!! Read more

We stop by this place after dinner, and we?re shocked at how awesome this place is. They have quite a large selection of ice... cream, and make everything themselves. We ended up getting the turtle sundae with coffee Oreo, dirty turtle and gator tracks.All of those scoops were absolutely delicious. Some of the best ice cream we?ve ever had. We do recommend this place. For somereason there are school banners all over the place inside for their decor. I was happy to find a banner for Texas A&M, my almamater, as well as the Dallas Cowboys. Read more

WOW!!! Amazing ???? I read reviews of this place and many others, and decided that this was the place to try. I am sooo glad... that I did. The ice cream was spectacular ????. It was in a shopping plaza on Sanibel Island ???? and it was constantly busy.We thoroughly enjoyed the taste and experience. Wonderful dessert ????, you will NOT be disappointed. It was a little pricey,until we saw the amount that they dished out for us. We highly recommend ???? Read more

Incredible ice cream!! Loved this place- unique and fun ice cream flavors- got a ?kid? scoop and it was two scoops AND you could... get two different types of ice cream for each scoop! Really cute shop and area of Sanibel! Had different parrots around theshop to check out. Read more

Holy cow, I was not expecting this place to be so good! I first saw a Love Boat in Fort Myers, and it sounded kind of cute to me... but it also didn?t appeal enough to go try it. But this is one of the only ice cream shops on Sanibel Island so we decided to gofor it, and boy am I glad we did!! First of all, be aware when you order a normal waffle cone, even the ?small? one comes withFOUR, *4* scoops of ice cream, as seen pictured below. It?s awesome but it?s also a lot so be prepared for that if you do orderit. My favorite ever from here is the Oatmeal Cream Pie ice cream. Yup, it?s really a flavor and it?s fricken fantastic! Smallpieces of oatmeal cookie and a whole lot of wonder. The Coconut Almond Fudge is also a really popular flavor and it?s prettygood even for me who doesn?t prefer those kinds of flavors. But they have so many different options and this ice cream willimprint on you, it?s so good. Really, I don?t get impressed by ice cream often but this place really took me by surprise. Andthe lady working was sooo nice too, so all around so worth the wait and trip! Read more

A must if you are in Sanibel Island and looking for an ice cream place to eat. Super cute themed restaurant in an awesome... location. They are located inside the Jerry?s Foods Plaza which is covered with tall trees that provides shaded areas in caseyou choose to eat out side and enjoy the breeze that comes from the beach or take pictures with the parrot right in thecourtyard. Now, the amount of flavors they have is almost overwhelming. Not a complaint, just quite a lot to choose from and ifyou like a lot of flavors then choosing can become very hard. You can ask the staff to try the flavors before making a finaldecision. I have tried the blueberry cheesecake which is delicious, Salted caramel bacon which was not my cup of tea, birthdaycake which was what we got for the kids, mudslide and rocky road which is what I got on a cup and a cone on top of it. The icecream shop is pretty small so there might not always be space to seat depending on the time of the day and year you visit butremember that there are also tables outside where you can sit. Their prices are fair : Kid Cone or cup - $4 Small cone or cup - $5 Large cup - $6 Waffles are 0.50 cents extra They also have milk shales, malts, floats, freezies and sodas as well as coffeebeverages. Love this location just as much as I love the one in Fort Myers beach. Read more