Reviews for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Sandy Springs GA in Sandy Springs, GA

I was lucky enough to try samples of different pies at Food That Rocks when Buttermilk Sky Pie had a booth there earlier this... year. I was informed to sign up for the birthday club and I would receive a free mini pie and I quickly did. I received my emaillast month and I gladly went to go pick up the pie. There were so many pies to choose from but I decided on apple since ittasted so good the first time I tried it. Unfortunately I had a 45 minute drive home and the pie did not make it back since Iimmediately ate it once I got in the car. Next time I return, I will definitely pick up one then one. Don't walk, run to trytheir pies! Read more

MOLD ON PIE- Just came back from leaving a good review of their pies only to find out mold growing over their small pumpkin pie... freshed purchased a couple hours ago. Called the owner immediately, the owner offered refunding the small pumping pie with mold.But looking at other pies we purchased from here the same time, we don't know how safe it is to consume. We don't feel safe toconsume the other pies as we don't know if the mold is just one instance. We would expect they at least refund the entire ordersince mold on food is a serious issue. ------------------------------ We love their pies. Butternut milk and granny apples areour favorites. We have came back multiple times driving over 1 hour each way to get their pie cause we love theflavor. Customer service is pretty okay. While I was there, the owner got a call from another customer and complained to meafterwards that people always wanted personal customization on the pie. She said, and quoted, "they do not want this and do notwant that on the pie, so why don't they make their own pie?" I find it pretty rude, though admittedly I understand customizationwould add much more work to the batch process. Really suggest the owner to add a note on the website for personal customization. Read more

Buttermilk Sky Pie serves several different pies on a rotating basis. Pictured here is the I-40 which is more or less a pecan... pie with chocolate chips and coconut flakes. So good. I've also had the coconut cream and peanut butter pie which are mypersonal favorites. You can order through the website which is super easy and quick. The staff is really friendly and helpfulas well. I'll definitely be back. Read more

Great service and nice shop, but the pies we got do not taste like pies. Whatever they used for the pies crust was not pie... crust. It was some kind of insanely sweet cookie or something, which made everything way too sweet to eat. The coconut cream piehad some kind of rubbery cream on top that is great for presentation and travel, but not the experience that I was seeking. Thecoconut cream was just overwhelming sweetness, and so I was not able to discern any coconut cream flavor. This was not bad"pie," it just wasn't for me. Read more

My husband and I love their pies! The chocolate cream and peanut butter are our favorites, but we also love the fruit pies. It?s... hard to beat their apple pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. We love that they make the individual size pies so we can trymultiple flavors each time we visit. Highly recommend checking them out if you?re in the neighborhood! Read more

Hands down one of the best peacan pie in town!!! The richness, the sweetness, the bite, the crust was all on point! Their crust... is not your usual pie crust! It's abit more cookie like and it's so darn delicious? Read more

Had one of those days and needed a sweet fix. ???? Was on my way home and stopped by this place and got us two mini cream pies,... one peanut butter the other chocolate. They were packed with such care in these little black plastic holders with a little cleardome on top. Definitely carry-out friendly! The place was clean and I was welcomed right when I walked into the door.. it's thelittle things that matter.~ now on to the pies themselves.. I have got to say, the peanut butter pie was one of the best I'veever had and definitely solved my sugar cravings. The chocolate pie was also amazing. Not overly sweet and definitely creamy.?????????10/10 will definitely stop by here again and try some of their other menu items. Attached a photo of my receipt forproof since we legit devoured them when we got home. ???? Read more

Great place to take a date. There is the old country apple ???? crumb in mini size. We purchased the coconut ???? and the 1-40... pecan pie mini. I Prefer the coconut and but the pecan was a favorite as well.. They also have fresh ice cream from the farmto go with your pie. We didn't get ice cream this time. The customer service awesome ????. Read more