Reviews for Tony's Pizza in Sanborn, NY
Ordered a sheet pizza at 1:30 to be ready at 3:30 to make sure they had plenty of time because of the game. Not sure if they... made it when I called but it was very dry. 38 bucks, I won't take that chance again Read more
Pizza had puddles of liquid, which I imagine was from canned toppings not being drained, or something. Caused the cheese to... slough off and the dough was like wet bread. Read more
Pretty good pizza (especially if you like 'sweet sauce'). Other items range from finger foods to submarine sandwiches. All are... "not bad"...... Definitely better places around..... Read more
I usually love the pizza here but these young kids they got working tonight NO RESPECT threw my pizza box across the counter... overcooked it?s the crust was dark and burnt and idk what happened but it left puddles of grease that soaked thru the pizza likenot normal I?ll show picture but the kids are super rude and disrespectful the young girl and the guy cooking the pizza superdisrespectful then asked when manager will Be in tomorrow and she hung up On me!!!! Read more
Stinger pizza hit the spot! The chicken fingers are good. Could of been more steak but definitely will be back for more.
Have been a customer of this location through out 2 ownership changes but will not return. The kid that works behind the counter... is discussing, this is not my first issue with him. He grabs the slices out of the slice warmer with the spatula, drops theslice on the bottom of the warmer picks that same slice with his hands and puts it in the box. Worst $8 I ever spent. Couldn?teven eat the pizza as there were pieces of charred plastic in it as you can see from the picture. This is literally how he putthe pizza on the counter. Customer service has went way down hill! Read more
My wife was visiting New York from California and stopped in here for dinner. The owner was very accommodating and made her a... vegan pizza. She smuggled some home for me and this definitely needs to be on the menu! She said the crust was perfect and thetoppings were flavorful and fresh. Definitely recommend trying them out if you are in the area. Read more
Yesterday evening, my fiancé and I ordered a couple pizzas from Tony's Pizza Sanborn. Nothing fancy: just a large cheese and... pepperoni along with a large veggie. When he arrived to pick up the order he was informed they dropped the veggie pizza gettingit out of the oven. They advised they were making another one. In the meantime our cheese and pepperoni was just going to sit.Don asked to please put the pizza on top of the oven to attempt to keep it warm. Within 10 minutes the veggie pizza was done.Which is weird - pizzas like that with extra topping usually take a longer to cook. When we sat to eat I noticed the pizzaseemed undercooked. It was paper thin. I ate one piece and that was it. Later, I became very nauseous, had terrible stomachpain and was unable to sleep all night. It had to have been the undercooked dough. Don phoned Tony's Pizza and made them awareof what transpired. Unfortunately, they would not accept any blame in this matter. The supervisor/manager was very curt - tryingto explain why the pizza turned out the way it did. (We spoke with a female supervisor/manager.) We attempted to at least get areplacement pizza - which they would not entertain. This had quickly become our favorite place for pizza. Unfortunately, the waythey handled the matter was disappointing. Read more