Reviews for Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop in San Mateo, CA

First time I had a sandwich at this location. Although I'm probably wrong, bread tasted like day old bread

What can I say...Scrumptious. Mr. Pickle's is your ol' school hole in the wall sandwiche shop and has never let me down. The... sandwiches are a good size. Just 1 and I'm set for lunch and dinner. Friendly staff and fast service. Can get busy around lunchtime. Some might find them to be a little pricey (mine was $11 and some change) but definitely worth it. Read more

Got the Tony Soprano, great sandwich, fast service and kind employees. Good value for cost.

Charge EXTRA FOR CHEESE $2.00, AND THEN BECAUSE IT WAS SWISS CHEESE ANOTHER $2.00. THEN The receipt says that the sandwich is... supposed to be HEATED!!!! It was not HEATED it was cold!!! They delivered it in a plastic bag with the receipt tape on outsideof plastic bag!!! Read more

Mr. pickles is a staple of the San Mateo, they have a sandwich dedicated to all the local high schools. All the employees are... incredibly nice. Definitely stop by, they have something for everyone. Read more

I had been here previously, twice, and the sandwiches were never great. I decided to try it again today and it was wonderful.... Had the tuna sandwich, toasted with pepper jack cheese on white bread, add ranch and jalapeños. The price for two sandwiches,two drinks, and two chips was $34 which seems outrageous to me. Read more

I've been a big fan of Mr pickles not just the San Mateo location but have enjoyed the San Bruno and Daly City locations as well... as the one in San Francisco. Unfortunately this experience was not very good. Ordered my favorite which was the Tony Soprano.Have been ordering this for years and always asks for extra mortadella and no ham. Never once is anybody not done it right. Thesandwich that was given to me was as if the person who made it had no clue what Mr pickles was or all about. I literally had oneslice of mortadella in the sandwich and a few slices of salami. Horribly made sandwich. Somebody really messed up. We left and Igot down the block I thought I should check the sandwich because it did feel kind of light. Had to order the same sandwich formy colleague when I handed it to him it was definitely heavier than mine. Pulled over checked it out and of course it wasactually kind of scary that it came out the way it did. Fortunately we were less than a mile away so I turned around and wentback. They remade the sandwich for me but almost reluctantly. And when they handed me the new sandwich no one apologize for theinconvenience and the fact that they really screwed up. I get it they were probably all embarrassed, but the reality is, itshould have never happened. When I was 5 years old my dad put more meat in the sandwiches and when I got from them. It'll be awhile before I return to that particular Mr pickles, thank God there's many others to go to!! Read more

Looked like an old school sandwich shop so I stopped and it was definitely worth it! The guy behind the counter was friendly and... help me out and finally I chose one and customized it a bit... Pastrami and turkey with cream cheese, avocado, lettuce, tomato,and honey mustard on Dutch crunch bread. Let me say that I haven't been this excited about a sandwich in a long time! This wasreally good! The boylan creme soda made it even better! Can't wait to go back and try some others! Read more