Reviews for Pie Society in San Marcos, TX
Pizza and garlic knots were delicious. Pie was tastey but as someone who worked in pizza a long time the quality control could... be a little better. Pie had a large spot where the dough bubbled. Watching other pies cook saw same issue. Besides that theatmosphere was great and staff was friendly. Would definitely try them again. Read more
This is a great meet up place! The plaza this place is in is pretty small which gets packed pretty fast so be aware. The place... wasn?t crazy big and we arrived at 11:30 for lunch and I?m glad we did cause it started filling up. The staff was super friendlythough, answered all the questions I had since it was my first time in. Basically when you enter you find your seat then head tothe front bar to place your order. No waiters just staff in general delivering your food and beer if you ordered it. They alsohad soda, tea and water. I enjoyed their blueberry soda. We ordered a pepperoni slice, Balance of power pie, the pyramid pizzatoppings and added fennel sausage made into a calzone and the 78-666 pizza toppings made into a calzone. My pyramid calzone wassuper delicious and big so leftovers for sure. Tons of cheese so chew chew chew so you don?t choke haha. Everyone in my partyenjoyed their food and complimented on how good it was so we have zero complaints. Things to note only one stall restroom formen and women but was nice and clean. Would definitely go back for sure. Read more
Pizza was delicious. I came in about 6:30pm and the pizza was hot and tasty. Staff was kind and attentive. And the Pinot Noir... was just super good. Read more
We were greeted immediately and introduced to the establishment. Had wonderful service by Bailey, and River! The pyramid pizza... was amazing and you can order by the slice several different types before 8! The dough was not too salty but made the crustthin and crispy. The restaurant was clean and comfortable! We will come again!!!! Read more
We were there on Thursday 6/23. We were there put of town on a baseball tournament and found this quaint and cute establishment.... We ordered The Handshake and a cheese calzone. The cheese calzone was the size of both my hands put together. The pizza wasthe best we have had in a long time. It was piping hot and the cheese was ooey-gooey. The ingredients were so fresh. Thepictures don't do it justice. Wished we had this establishment in my area. Read more
This was our first visit to PS. All the reviews implied that they had the best pizza in town. Well.....the beer was good. We got... a split pie: one side with sausage and the other with pepperoni, green peppers (never got on) garlic, onions. The pizza hadlittle to no sauce, minimal veggies, sparse meat but HEAVY garlic. The crust though was good. We also got a Caesar salad. It wasa good salad but again, a heavy hand with the garlic which rendered the salad a bit unpleasant to eat. We love garlic but thiswas too much. ???? I am sorry to say but it was disappointing. We will continue to search for somewhere local (Austin's Via 313is some of the best we ever had but not local) that actually have good pizza. Read more
Always amazing pizza! My favorites are the 78666 and pyramid, though some of the best are their pies of the day. Had the best... one ever, something with Tabasco and ranch in the sauce and I would have absolutely eaten numerous slices of that. This is amust try place for pizza. Read more
6 dollars for a single slice of reheated pizza is just too much. Their product is a good quality. Crust is flaky and cheeses are... good, as well as the drinks. Their happy hour pricing would be worth going again, but I wouldn?t pay full price. Read more