Reviews for Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan in San Juan Capistrano, CA

The food was great. The people at the front were a little busy to seat us but the Manager came over, sat us, answered all of our... questions and took our order. He was great and we could see he is a very active leader. Most businesses would fair better withhim at the helm. Read more

My wife and I visited this restaurant for the 3rd time and thoroughly enjoyed both the food, service and atmosphere. It was a... beautiful day and we sat outside in the lovely patio with fireplace. It was wine Wednesday, so we enjoyed a delicious bottleof pinot grigio paired with the Fetalicious salad, their homemade sourdough rolls and an authentic Chicago cheese pizza. Fordessert we enjoyed the mothership which consisted of a homemade baked in a pan chocolate chip cookie with 2 scoops of Vanillaice cream. I highly recommend this even if you're full. Our server Tatum did a wonderful job and was very attentive to ourneeds. The manager stopped by our table numerous times to see if we needed anything. In summary, great food, atmosphere, serviceand location. Looking forward to our next visit! Read more

Selma's Chicago Pizzeria is an incredible restaurant. There are multiple locations around the area. This particular one requires... a paid parking lot, but the other ones are available with free parking. The staff here is great. The menu is extensive. Theirbeer selection is wonderful. Bring your entire family and enjoy their food. They show sports on their televisions in the bararea. They do have rooms that are available for private events if you are so inclined. At least one of the owners is a familyman, and that goes a long way in my book. Read more

Food was dry and subpar. Boneless Wings were almost inedible and I was hungry. Service was prompt and nice. The owner was nice... and replayed to my review within several hours of posting. Read more

The pizza, the Mac-n-cheese was gross, the calamari was frozen and freezer burnt. The pizza was great but the service sucked. We... waitef 10 min before bring seated....that was fine. Then all the staff talked about was how they only had 1 chef because onequit and the chef was getting overwhelmed. If they say more then 5 tables, the waitresses would get confused. Read more

Gotta rave about this restaurant. I have been trying to find good Chicago style deep dish pizza in California for 23 years and... found it here, quite by accident. My Wife and I both are originally from Chicago, and we are very familiar with what makes agood, no, great deep dish pizza. This place got it right! We split a small size, with only Italian sausage (good qualitysausage too), we started off with the regular size Italian chopped salad. This was plenty of food for us both and probably toomuch for a couple of average eaters. The staff was courteous and helpful, very professional. The restaurant was clean and verypleasant, with windows open to the sidewalk and an outdoor patio. There is a full bar which features a happy hour menu. Therestrooms were well maintained, clean and fully stocked. Service was quick. The price for all this was not bad either! We hadtwo iced teas as well, and the bill, with tax, came out to just $36.96! About what you would pay for a couple of burgers in acasual dining restaurant. All in all, I, we highly recommend this restaurant and will be coming back again. Read more

Really good pizza. The deep dish is excellent. The sampler appetizer is also quite good. We really liked the toasted raviolis... and the fried cheese. They were a little short-staffed in the kitchen so the appetizer came out a little slow, but they compedus for it. We will definitely come back. Read more

We're big Selma's fans. Chill pizza joint with good bar food, salads, sandwiches and options to accommodate all diets such as... vegan, gluten free and keto. Parking is usually pretty easy in the structure around the corner, but you may have to park on theroof. Good options for families and big parties. Nice outdoor dining options, rotating taps and sports always playing. Servers are always pleasant. Pizza can be expensive because of the quality ingredients and crust options. Accepts all creditcards. If you find this post helpful please like! Read more