Reviews for Hildy's Pizza in St Simons Island, GA
I had heard good thing's about the pizza at hildy's, unfortunately it wasn't! I ordered two pizzas, one specialty meat pizza and... a pepperoni pizza. Both pizza's had terrible crust and very few toppings. It didn't taste good at all. The pictures on yourwebsite looked like great pizza, one I got didn't look like that. I will not get pizza from hildy's again. Read more
Wow that was an excellent pizza (The Italian Queen). Best pizza I've had in years...thumbs up!
Maybe my expectations are too high but this pizza was only okay to me. I was really hoping for delicious, based on the positive... reviews. The toppings were great, but the sauce was too sweet and the dough was undercooked. All in all, nobody left the tablehungry but it wasn?t exactly a hit. Read more
The pizza was yummy and the staff was super friendly. It's a real local, family feel pizzeria. Our pizza was done pretty quickly... even though they were very busy. Read more
UPDATE: We went back and tried the bread sticks. SO GOOD! The company made up for the forgotten bread sticks. Great customer... service. 5 star on the pizza. The crust was wonderful. Wish they didn't forget the bread sticks, but the pizza was great. Read more
First time here for us. Excellent tasty pizza, crispy crust, served out of oven hot with great sauce and cheese. Served with... pepper flakes and grated cheese as well. Super friendly service and great to talk to. Great pizza place atmosphere. Inside andoutside seating. Very clean. Thank you! Read more
So here's the sadness that has engulfed my heart. I SO WANTED to make sweet love to their pizza. Our daughter goes to SSI... regularly and LOVES them. Maybe it was a bad night. They were CRAZY busy, so maybe that was part of the problem! But - we gota basic pepperoni pizza and it didn't seem to get fully cooked. We also got an order of the Hildy Bread and it had the sameissue. The pepperonis weren't even really done and the crust was kind of a little doughy. So - here's the deal... hadn't beento St. Simons in over 40 years and was there about a month ago. Now as life would have it, we're heading back next weekend andhoping to try them again if our group wants pizza. On a side note... they got more stars than may be rated, but they truly arethe NICEST folks around! Cook that pizza a little longer and they'll be around for decades! Read more
I give this a couple of stars because the service requested was good. As a resident, we wanted this restaurant to be successful.... And I think they are doing OK, but I will say as first time customers we were very disappointed. The pizza, as others havementioned, was simply not cooked. It was a very bland pizza that is not on par with many other establishments on the island.This could be remedied, but we will most likely be taking our business elsewhere for now. Read more