Reviews for Il Capuccino in Sag Harbor, NY

Nice atmosphere and good and friendly service. Food, however, was only average. We had fun on our anniversary on a small road... trip through here but won't be back to this restaurant. Read more

Our family of 5 ate there for dinner. Waited a long time for our waitress. By the time she came to the table we were ready to... order everything. Drinks, apps and entree’s. Strictly talking food… apps were good . Entrees were mediocre. I ordered aglass of wine that still hadn’t arrived by the time I was almost done with dinner. I was going to tell her to just skip it atthis point but a food runner ended up bringing it. We saw our waitress twice. Once to order and once to bring our check. Thefood runners filled our waters and the kids soda’s. When she dropped the check, my husband was surprised. The soda’s were6.00 apiece ( 3 kids) and we were charged for 8 of them. Soda prices were not listed on the menu and as the food runnerscontinued to refill soda, never once said anything. My husband very politely inquired about the charge and her response was soawful and completely demeaning… about how we were ,” in sag harbor during the summer”. My husband quietly nodded, signedthe check and we left. He left her no tip… my husband has NEVER done that as he managed fine dining restaurants for years.Upon returning home he checked our credit card statement and was not surprised to find that they added a fifty dollar tipthemselves. We are disputing Read more

The bread was incredible, it’s not usually the highlight of my meal but last night it was. The eggplant parm was top notch as... well as the little neck clams. Overall the quality and price makes this a very reasonable meal. Will Certainly go back. Read more

The bread was EVERYTHING, the salmon was juicy and the sauce on top was fire! The 2 veges they could've kept and the zucchini... was undercooked ???? Rice was ehhh considering it's brown rice. No pizzazz. Taste delicious going down, I was sick afterwards,but I blame the margarita ???? When in doubt... I'd go again to give it another try ???? Read more

The garlic rolls are addictive, I had 3!! The split pea soup, yum but the codfish special was ok, great piece of fish, not... knocking that but it was missing some flavor. Now others may disagree, my taste buds have been ruined with spicy foods so Ialways need a huge burst of flavor, but still delicious. Plus the hostesses and our server were great! Will definitely come backoh and I don't typically eat meat but did try a bite of the Riley and it was pretty damn good. It's hard to find good red meatin America! Read more

UPDATED REVIEW: New ownership, and i no longer like it. The garlic knots changed. They no longer use fresh garlic, they use the... pre minced garlic that sits in oil. It was nowhere close to my experiences 3 years ago. Very disappointing. Eggplant parm wassalty, veal was chewy and overcooked, garlic knots were not the same. So upsetting and I will not be back. • Worth the wait.Staff was very kind, and the food was amazing. Best garlic knots i've ever had! Read more

Delicious food! My husband enjoyed the Salmon salad and he is very picky. My seafood was delicious and I got enough portions of... the shrimp, clams, and mussels. The prices are good for their portion sizes. Jack our waiter was amazing! He was very attentiveand kind. Would definitely go again. Read more

Had a great dinner here, from the garlic knots to the burrata to the fettuccine Alfredo. Have to take off a star, though, since... even with a reservation we waited for at least 20 minutes past the time we had set up. It was also pretty noisy inside anddifficult to hear each other. Menu was very affordable, though, and would recommend if you want some tasty Italian food andaren’t in a rush. Read more