Reviews for Goldberg’s Famous Bagels in Sag Harbor, NY
When you walk into a deli/bagel place, you don't expect much...food wise but when I ordered a cheeseburgers platter, OMG, it... was the best tasting burger and delicious fries I almost ever had in my life. Thank God I don't live there, I'd be thereeveryday. Great job for being in the middle of nowhere guys. Read more
Omare made sure to keep me waiting just because I mentioned I was first in line. He threw things at the counter. When I checked... with the staff why my order was taking so long they mentioned he was really taking his time and that only he could deliver myorder. Unbelievable how a person can be mean just because. Read more
Even if you ask for a highly toasted bagel, they schmear on a mountain of cold cream cheese (even if you ask for a light... amount), rendering the bagel cold by the time you can sit down and eat it. Total madness in the mornings as well. Read more
Fresh croissant made on site , warm, fluffy , truly amazing. Day old, possibly reheated croissant not so much. Even if you ask... they say all made " in this morning" . I understand they need to sell everything, but if you ask , also if you regular customer.Come on!!! Read more
Very good New York bagels right on main street. I wish the inside was a little nicer but it still hits the spot. The Hobo... sandwich on a roll is a hearty, savory morning experience to try! The tofu cream cheese is notably good! There is also a smalllocal provisions area inside. Bagels will come wrapped in paper, then paper foil, and in a plastic bag if you get more than 2 Read more
Horribly rude, abrasive and condescending front counter and register staff. Having been a Goldberg?s Katonah and East Hampton... customer for years I can tell you that this location can?t hold a candle to the former local bagel location in Sag Harbor, BagelBuoys. Do t bother and make the trip to East Hampton location, much nicer staff! Read more
Lives up to its hype. They are very accommodating to making exactly your order. Every specific detail of each and every bagel... was spot on. They randomly sell Mike?s Hot Honey by the bottle which is hard to find and normally something I have to orderonline. No need to toast the bagel twice if you like it crispy, once it perfectly toasted. Extra cream cheese is the move. Read more
We stopped there for a quick lunch. We ordered sandwiched and they were really good. They have a lot of choices too. Price was... okay and had a good service. Read more