Reviews for Cromer's Market in Sag Harbor, NY
I don't even bother going in to look around for inspiration let alone shop there. I've heard alot of bad things about it and... that the staff is very rude. Read more
Don't bother stopping at this place. Their fried chicken is supposed to be good. I ordered thighs which generally retain their... moisture. There was no moisture in these at all as if they had been sitting all day. I asked for Claires coleslaw what I got wasclear coleslaw. Whatever that is, it is not Claires coleslaw. Perhaps the deli staff should learn English and what is on theirown menu. Tasteless food at premium prices. Read more
The food is excellent, but the service is inconsistent at best and abysmal at worst. It?s one thing when they get your order... wrong the first time, it?s another when you expect them to get it wrong every time. For what you?re paying for, its afrustrating experience. Pick your battles. Read more
I've been here many times, and it never fails to please. The meat that they sell here is great, I've grilled countless burgers,... steaks, and kielbasa from here. I also love the breakfast sandwiches, Sausage egg and cheese is my favorite. I've also been ableto get good pies, ribs, mashed potatoes, fried chicken, and muffins. On top of that, I've been able to make quick trips there ifI ever want ice cream, as well as other things like snacks, drinks, and recipe ingridients. Read more
We buy all of our holiday foods at Cromer?s. there is nothing that compares on the East End. It?s nearly an hour drive from... our home, and worth every second. Absolutely the best service butcher shop. There are others out here that are excellent, butCromer?s is the best. Read more
Had a few surprise guests show up for the weekend . What better way to show our hospitality, then rib eye steaks? Cromer?s... butchers carved some of the finest ribeyes we have ever had . They tasted amazing !!!! Thank you for the excellentrecommendation. Read more
Great little store that can fill your big stomach with quality foods and refreshments. Great coffee :) Has good kombucha too
Everything looked good!!! Good roast beef and rare!! Rotisserie chicken super. Everything we bought was excellent!! All... employees in all departments were extremely helpful. Stacy, the manager, runs a good business. Read more