Reviews for American Hotel in Sag Harbor, NY
We went last night for our 42nd wedding anniversary. Fantastic Food n Drink. I had the Spinach Salad. Than Scallops with... creamy Mashed Potatoes n Green Cauliflower Husband had Ceasars Salad n than Lamb Chops .. EXCELLENT Read more
Fun and amazing, Restaurant is a old hotel with alot history.. men's toilet is a 2x2 lol... food good..service great..location... amazing..seen 5 movie stars siting amd eating casually..very cool...alot rich people come here... Read more
If you want to splurge on a classy formal dinner, this is the place. An institution. Been coming here for 30 years to... celebrate major occasions. The lobster bisque is a favorite. Read more
Fresh, delicious seafood and classic American dishes. The staff are some of the most polite, accommodating, and helpful I?ve... ever met. We had a large party?including three young children?but the staff helped fit us in and attended assiduously to ourtable. I will certainly be returning. Read more
Review is regarding the restaurant only. One of my favorites for over 25 years, has a historical feel to it, charming and old... world atmosphere, food has been very good and consistent over the years. Great martinis. An American classic. Read more
Incredible experience. Called to book a 2 night stay- business meeting in Sag Harbor. I was told that they couldn?t accommodate... me. I thanked them, then began to look into booking with Sag Harbor Inn or Barron?s Cove. Before I had a chance to book SagHarbor Inn ( which had availability) , I received a call back from American Hotel, telling me that they could accommodate me for2 nights. I then booked it. When I arrived at hotel on Sunday afternoon, I was told that I would need to move to another roomfor the 2nd night- I was a bit taken aback, but I went along with it to be helpful to them. The following morning around 11:00AM, I went to the front desk as I was leaving for a meeting, asking to move my things into the other room ( an ? apartment?- thenext level up). I was told that the room was not available and wouldn?t be for awhile. I asked for a key as I told the clerkthat I would be back very late. They wouldn?t give me a key for the apartment room.They told me there would not be any problemlater in the evening. Well here is the unbelievable part- I returned to the hotel around 10:45PM- the hotel was completelyclosed-locked up. I am with my bags and there is no one there! I had nowhere to stay that night. If gets better- I called thehotel the following morning explaining what happened. I asked to speak to the manager- I was told that he would call me as soonas he came into work. I called back at 3:00PM and was told that he had left for the day. Can you believe this!He never called meback.The clerk I spoke with at 3:00PM insisted that there was a bartender there at 11:00PM the night before and could have letme in.Well , I?d like to know where he or she was , as the place was locked up and dark- no one responded to my persistentknocking. I have stayed at the American Hotel on a few other occasions - this was a shocking and incredibly disappointingexperience. I will never stay there again- this experience was horrible. I would encourage you to stay aw Read more
This is a very good restaurant with very good service and very good food. They have a very extensive wine list and it's on the... expensive side to eat there. But if you want a top-notch restaurant with really good food, this is a great place to eat in SagHarbor Read more
The American hotel restaurant is the place we hangout for social and dinner. We love the service and quality of food. Do not... miss if you visit our town ? Sag Harbor ? Read more