Reviews for Da Mario Pizzeria in Rutherford, NJ
I went to this place after a long day of work to get dinner around 7:25 pm today Monday. I ordered at the cashier the lady seem... to be in a rush and she forgot I paid upfront in cash to make it easier and not make people wait. When I got the food shemisplaced my mozzarella sticks on another table and I had to let her know that?s my plate along with a slice of eggplant pizzawhich had women?s hair but I didn?t want to complain (I was trying to be nice because the lady was busy ). Besides that, shedidn?t gave me a cup or straw for my drink she just gave me a can. And other costumers had cups cause I made sure and lookedaround. After I ate the mozzarella sticks and finished my food. I went outside to wait for my Uber (because I live in New York Ionly went to Rutherford for work). This lady came OUTSIDE chased me with the bill cart saying MA?AM ! You OWE A BILL. Everybodyinside looked through the window (today being Halloween there was plenty of people there. I looked at her and said I alreadypaid you before I got my food. In cash. She said ?you did, ok no problem. ) she hesitated a little as if I was lying. And didn?teven apologized. this was a really bad experience for me I felt so bad and left. will never recommend or even come back to thatplace ever again!. Read more
I love your store when I order pizza it's always fresh and timely unlike ralphs you guys don't burn your pizzas
Love their food. Sent salad instead of pasta. They wanted the salad back and would give me the pasta. Hmmm why would you want... food back from a customer? Still waiting for my pasta. I did receive my pasta and I gave back the salad. Smh Read more
I love this place. My favorite food from this place is definitely the Penne Vodka pasta, I had penne vodka in many places, but... this location has the best one. Their pizza is also very good! Read more
Worst pizzeria ever , food is really nasty , seems like someone ate from my food. Got my food 2 hours later , manager so called... boss is very rude , food made me really sick never ever eating here $50 for no reason Read more
Very friendly staff and great pizza. Me and my 3 coworkers went there today, had a total of 12 slices. You get a lot for your... money and all good quality. Definitely recommend. Read more
Best pizza in town. They never disappoint. All the slices are great especially chicken parm, white, and grandma slice. Their... chicken parm dinner is the best. No hard pieces of chicken. We usually order a tray when we head down the shore for the week.The staff is extremely great as well. Read more
First class experience, service and the food was great. Rutherord?s finest.