Reviews for Lost Mountain BBQ Company in Romney, WV

The service was friendly and fast. We were surprised to learn that the dining area is all outside. It's covered but certainly... not heated. We ordered a full rack of ribs to split, and 4 sides. Our order came very fast, and it was accurate. Ribs were verymeaty and tender, flavorful. Loved the macaroni and cheese, coleslaw was creamy, not dry at all. We hadn't had lunch that day sowe were definitely hungry, but we couldn't finish anything there, it was all so filling. Going to have a great lunch thefollowing day. Definitely recommend this eatery. Read more

My parents catered with Lost Mountian BBQ for my sister's wedding over the past weekend. The ribs, pulled chicken and pork,... baked beans, Cole slaw and different sauces were delicious! Everyone went back for seconds and there was still plenty leftoverfor my sister to take home after. The owners are very nice and the husband has a great sense of humor. If I'm ever back in thispart of WV I'll be going back for some lunch! Read more

Occasionally, I like to go all out gluttony and get some menu item that is enormous and zero percent chance of me finishing it... in one sit down meal. Today, Lost Mountain bbq was my chance to try the "Romney Mountain Masterpiece" and wow! It was easilybig enough for 2 dinners, potentially 3. It was amazing! all 3 meats, cole slaw, nacho cheese and more on top of a giganticbaked potato. The S.O. got the "Lost Mountain" baker, she loved it. Read more

Finally! A place that actually knows how to smoke meat properly. The brisket is pulled properly, not shredded to bits, not cut... in lazy slices. Sauces are all great. It's an outdoor, walk-up and order situation, but they do have a bathroom and seating, andcover over seating and ordering area. Parking lot is a little tight and steep to get in and out of, but it's worth it! Read more

Unfortunately, as good as this food looked, we were disappointed. The mac and cheese was bland and the brisket was dry. The BBQ... sauce was overly sweet and did not compliment the Mac and cheese in any way. The chicken was cooked perfectly and was delicious.I asked for the firecracker chicken, I'm not sure if they gave me a normal chicken or not because the chicken I had had nospice, beware. Read more

Friendly service and outdoor seating was good. Ribs were perfect - I was nervous, but they were full of flavor and the meat was... soft and juicy. Mac & cheese was solid but I wish I had gotten the coleslaw. Hubby got it on top of the pulled pork sandwich andit was yummy. The honey bbq sauces were good but I would have LOVED a spicy one. We will definitely be back. P.S. Sweet teawasn't on the drink menu but they served it and it was delicious. EDIT: They DO have spicy bbq and it's delicious! Read more

Couldn't have been better. The Pulled Pork sandwich was wonderful, as well as the Mac and cheese. Huge servings. Will... definitely be returning . Read more

The food was good. I could tell it was handcrafted. They aren't trying to cut any corners here. I liked the beans. I wish the... ribs were cut before giving to the customers. It's tough to cut them with plastic cutlery. The whole experience is just nicer ifthe ribs can be picked up to eat as soon as the customer receives them. That doesn't mean they are tough ribs. The meat wasgood. I'd like to try to brisket next time. We traveled an hour to try and we'll do it again sometime. Read more