Reviews for American Pie of Rome in Rome, NY

3 slices for 8 bucks not a bad deal. Tonys thicker crust style. Decent flavor on the sauce. My slices were a little bit over... sauced and the crust was a bit undercooked Read more

First time getting pizza from here and it?s very salty:( can?t even eat it it?s gross? got the Betsy Ross pizza and it?s just so... so salty Read more

Pizza barely average. Front counter girl has the personality of a tree stump. Dirty tables. All the shakers on the condiment... bar were empty. Read more

The pizza was okay, not bad.... The wings were great! Nice friendly staff, I'd go back again 100%

I don?t ever leave reviews, but this needed to be said. I never order from new pizza places that open up, because everytime I do... instant disappointment! I know American pie isnt considered ?New? anymore..but tonight is the 1st time I had it. We only gotwings and fries, but it was perfect! The fries were seasoned well, the everything wings were Awesome! & my daughter really likedher mild wings.Definitely will ordering again! Read more

My daughter and I absolutely love this place! If we get pizza this is where we get it from! Their boneless wings are AMAZING!!!... The food there is absolutely great and so is the staff! Seriously would give 6 stars if I could! Read more

First time at this eatery and I was not in impressed with the pizza. There's no reason to have bad pizza in Rome, NY! The sauce... had zero flavor and there was a ton of it. Not enough cheese and very little pepperoni. It was priced nicely at $6.00 for twoslices and a soda and the service was friendly. There may be good items in the menu, so I have heard, but the pizza is not it.Bonus points for being opened on mother's day when all the other pizzerias were closed. Read more

The food was amazing the greens are beyond great deff going to go there from now on for lunch