Reviews for Anthony's Pizzeria & Family Restaurant in Rockaway, NJ

You can?t beat the quality of the food coming from here for the price. Thin crust pizzas are amazing and pasta dinners are... always more than enough to share. Staff is great and always friendly no matter how busy they are Read more

Old school Italian food reminds me of down neck, Belleville and Bloomfield areas. The food is delicious and the portions will... garantee a doggie bag going home. The wait staff is attentive and courteous. B.Y.O.B. Read more

I had pasta w/ broccoli. For such a simple dish it was so tasty. Must be that garlic! And such a large portion which i thought i... would have to doggie bag, but being there with friends and chatting for a few hours i finished it. So yummy. My husband had theseafood combo and said it was very good. He compares a dish like that to a restaurant in our area - we're not locals - and noplace has come close until now. That says a lot from a man who is short on compliments. And he needed a doggie bag for hisgenerous serving. This almost never happens with him. We are looking forward to another great meal at Anthony's. Read more

We catered last night from Anthony?s and everyone could not stop raving about the food. Best chicken francese ever, plus penne... vodka, eggplant parm, meatballs and amazing salads and rolls. Will not hesitate to cater from Anthony?s again!! Read more

Visiting from Chesapeake Va and stopped in to have silcian pizza from my favorite pizzeria when I lived in Jersey. Everything... was as perfect as I remember. Will return every time I visit friends and family. Great food, prices and service. Read more

WOW! This is my new favorite pizzeria. My husband's job is not far from Anthony's pizzeria and he often gets lunch from them.... Recently he brought home dinner for us and I was absolutely floored. I had the muscles with marinara sauce. It was delicious andthe muscles were abundant. My husband had the chicken parmesan. Both of us enjoyed large quantities that we were able to reheatthe next day. Read more

Ate two pies this weekend, and both didn?t disappoint. Amazing food. Grew up eating this pizza, and the taste and quality has... not changed a bit. Keep up the good work team! Read more

Decided to give this restaurant a try, I order the Carbonara pita, chicken farm slice, white slice, meatlovers slice and an... order of calamari. All the food was overcooked and dry, the carbonara was sliced ham, this was a horrible experience and wouldnot recommend, even the bread is bad, im sorry but please get a handle on your cooking. I ended up throwing $40 worth of foodout. Here are the pictures of the disgusting food. Read more