Reviews for Johnny's Pizzeria & Restaurant in Rock Tavern, NY
I'm from GA! Had to try some NY Pizza! It was AWESOME!! The taco slice was amazing! The garlic knots were probably some of the... best I've ever had! Shout out! Read more
First time ordering food from Johnny?s Pizzeria and I enjoyed my breakfast burger with Chicken soup! The staff where warm and... welcoming. I?am definitely coming back to try the pizza. Read more
My husband has fallen in love with Johnny?s pizza since we moved to the area from Ulster County. He?s fairly particular about... what he likes for pizza and Johnny?s delivers! His favorites are the traditional cheese, Beacon, and Buffalo chicken pizzas. Thestaff are also always nice and we?ve NEVER had an issue with accuracy or quality. If you?re in the area, try it out, you won?tbe sorry! Read more
Ordered for pickup not expecting much, but was surprised at the quality of the service and food we received. Garlic knots were... tasty and the pizza crust had a good crisp. The owner was very friendly and made us feel like regulars, will definitely go backnext time I?m in town. Read more
Breakfast sandwich was good, but a bit too salty for my taste. Service was made to order quick. Coffee was good. Their menu has... some promising sandwich combinations that I would like to try. I plan on going back the next time I visit my friend down state. Read more
Went to NY for a graduation. My biggest goal was to get some great NY pizza. Johnny's was recommended by a Friend so we gave... them a call because we were getting there close to closing time and wanted to get our order in. Had perfect pepperoni pizza,just like I had hoped for! The best antipasto salad I have ever had in my life and a order of eggplant topped it off! Worthdriving from Virginia for food this good! Thank you Johnny and team!! Read more
Friendly faces, great pizza and hot sandwiches, and let's not forget the awesome desserts! If they still make it, I'll never... forget the best Chicago pizza! Always enjoyed lunch here when I worked in Newburgh. A welcoming and comfortable spot. Often hadmeals delivered to the office. Service is prompt (delivery or eat-in), prices are good, inside is clean and bright. They makeyou feel at home. RECOMMENDED! ???? Read more
VERY EXPENSIVE and NASTY! Bought a plain and a pepperoni garlic slice. Came out to $8.80. Bought slices were under cooked. I... could roll the dough back into a ball. The pepperoni itself was undercooked. Barely any sauce. Watery taste. Lots of flop. Mindyou, I asked for it extra crispy. The overall taste was very synthetic. I threw out both slices and felt sick afterwards.Something was off. Rather buy Red Baron frozen pizza. Save your money go elsewhere Read more