Reviews for Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Rochester, NY

Great place to watch footballl.. bartenders were awesome... great service...

The little midget guy who makes subs in the back, I think his name is John is the best! He makes the bomb diggity subs. For a... short guy he sure does put his meat on the table! Read more

Excellent food and awesome customer service. All around fantastic experience.

Had a great time, lots of seating but it was really cold inside; colder inside than out. Great fish dinner and wait... staff...KUDOS Read more

Still have not found a pizza better than Salvatore's. I've tried others. Mark's, Pudgies, and many of the smaller shops. None of... them seem to have the quality of pizza that Salvatore's has. Read more

We Had a retirement party there on Thursday night for the school for the deaf and Retirement for one of the teachers. The... service was outstanding, the food was outstanding. I have to give a shout out to Paula, & Jennifer they were on top of thingsand mingled with people at the party while serving us! The kitchen staff was wonderful to work with and another shout out toToni who came out to introduce herself! Thank you everyone for making the party so special and a nite to remember! Sincerely Tim& Geno! Read more

Best. Pizza. Ever!!! I ordered a custom large pizza with mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers, tomato, spinach, pepperoni... and Genoa salami with Alfredo sauce and omfg this was the best pizza I've ever had in my life! It was perfectly juicy, warm,tasty and amazing. It was around $40 with all the toppings, but damn it was worth it! I don't ever want to go to any other pizzaplace ever again. I swear, Salvatore's pizza is famous for a reason. Read more

A decent place to grab food and drinks. Prices are on the more expensive side and I don?t feel like the quality or service or... atmosphere really matches the prices being higher than lost all other subs/pizza joints. Still it?s a decent place to go forslices or to sit with a group of people. Steak on the sub I got today had not great flavor and had a rubbery texture. Read more