Reviews for Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Rochester, NY

Prices are a bit high compared to other pizza places, but the service is great and the quality of the food is stellar.

Called in a take out order for a pizza and boneless wings. The bill was over $35 with no sauce on the wings (cup of dipping... sauce on the side) in a small to go container and the pizza was what I would consider a medium on a good day. The staff seemeddisorganized and the counter man was surrounded by plexiglass so much that he couldn't hear anyone while I was waiting for myfood. The food was below normal quality for the area and the pizza was disappointing. Read more

Delicious pizza. Pleasant atmosphere Super friendly employees. I went with my family to spend some time and we had a great... time. They were very kind and attentive. And we didn't need anything at any time. Because they were always on the lookout at alltimes. I fully recommend them. It's cool to go for a while to see games and sports points. Anyway, I really liked the place andthe food. Read more

Love the sausage pepperoni pizza. I grab a slice sometimes at lunch and I usually grab a blue cheese for dipping. Thanks for... great good and great service from staff. Read more

If I could rate a 0 I would. We ordered a sheet, a large, and wings and the delivery man came with wings and just the large and... asked for 70 dollars. If that is truly your prices, you are robbing people. Second, our entire sheet was missing with a housefull of people. We were told it would be 40 more dollars and an hour before the sheet would come with absolutely no compensationor care for us for their mess up. Horrible service. Would never order again or recommend. Read more

Being from out of town, had no idea what to expect. Ordered a meatball sub and Buffalo chicken salad along with Buffalo sausage.... All were great, food ready on time. Staff friendly, will diffinatly go back again. Thank you Read more

The 15 years i?ve been on this earth, i?ve never tasted a pizza worse then this. Number one, this pizza was TOO saucy, tasted... like pasta sauce. My family has been ordering from this place for over ten years, and the quality just went down honestly. Evenmy cat wouldn?t eat this. Read more

SALVATORES PIZZA cannot seem to get my order of boneless wings correct. I ask for extra sauce and cooked light and EVERY time... they're dry and overcooked. Not worth it. Read more