Reviews for Cordello's Pizzeria in Rochester, NY
We have been customers of Cordellos for a long time ; excellent food and excellent customer service. Since COVID most business?... customer service has been put on the back burner, (pun intended) not Cordellos. These were the best wings we?ve ever had in ourlives tonight. (Sauce is garlic parm & magic sauce mixed, cooked well done). Read more
Ordered 2 garbage plates for myself and my mother a couple of days ago. Mac and potato salad passable but nothing special. ... Onion rings and waffle fries good. But the burgers were like flavorless. dried out hockey pucks. Would not recommend and I wouldhesitate to order from there again. Read more
In the last 5 years I have never got a bad Pizza or even a slice of pizza that was not perfect. Their subs are fantastic with... fresh baked bread and their wings I can't say enough about Read more
I had high expectations as menu was abundant and staff greeted me at the door with smiles and good energy. I ordered 2 slices (1... cheese, 1 pep)?.After adding some fixings (parm & garlic powder) and a dip of ranch, I took my first bite & was SADLYdisappointed. Maybe if I had ordered a fresh full pizza out the oven it would have been better but MAN, it was cold and soft andtasteless. TBH one of worst slices of pizza I?ve ever had. This is NY! We gotta do better guys? Read more
just ordered a steak sub there today (cordello's on chili ave. near union st.) & let me tell you it's the BEST steak sub i've... ever had. good customer service too. my order was perfect! good sub thanks to tom & denise. i will only get my subs from there.am going to get a pizza from them also. you'll love their food. cordello's is the only place that i will stop & get my subs. avery first time satisfied customer. candy. Read more
We're locals and this place is always our go-to. The staff is always so friendly and attentive, the food is great, and the price... is so reasonable. We love the pizza, ingredients always seem fresh, including the crust - great texture and flavor. Read more
Unfortunately I didn?t read the reviews before ordering. Got a pizza with black olives and pepperoni. The pizza was not great... over all. From the sauce to the cheese to the crust they all were all pretty bland and flavorless. the crust was weirdly chewyand hard to eat without your jaw hurting by the end. Additionally the black olives were full of pits. I have never had thisexperience before let alone 3 times in one pizza. Between my family we ate about 5 pieces of the pizza and 3 separate pieces hadolive pits. I almost broke my tooth and having fed this to a toddler who loves black olives this is an absolute choking hazard.Next time I?d rather eat little caesars. I wish I could give no stars on this review but that?s not an option. We still have alittle more then half a pizza left and I don?t think refrigerating it is going to do it any favors. A very unfortunateexperience and a waste of your hard earned money. Do yourself a favor and order somewhere else. Read more
New to the area, decided to give them a try. Called seven times, no one answered! Ordered from Mark's instead.