Reviews for Amico's Pizza in Rochester, NY
Great pizza, 2 topping large for $23. I forgot to put 2 blue cheeses on my online order, and so I tried to pay for them, and... the young lady said don't worry about it. That was the most impressive part! Thank you! 4 outta 5 stars, cause it coulda used alittle more sauce, but great place! Cheers! Read more
We had a pepperoni pizza - which was solid. The best part was chatting with Dave and his son's while we waited for the pizza to... cook. After 15 minutes, it felt like we'd known them forever and were friends. Skip the chain pizza places ... This is where youwanna go. Read more
Delicious pizza with the best service. They went above and beyond to help my family (3 small kids struggling while traveling)... enjoy a great meal. Read more
We've been customers for about 10 years. Hands down the best breakfast pizza in the city! I also love their NYC style thin... crust, the homemade ingredients, and how accommodating the staff has been to meet complicated orders. Read more
I ordered a large pizza with 20 wings tonight. The pizza was pretty good, however the topping distribution was pretty poor. I... had half cheese and half with mushroom and onion. There were almost no mushrooms on the pizza and what was on it was only on aquarter of the pie. Still overall a good tasting pizza. The WINGS however were honestly terrible. The sauce was great but themeat was rubbery and had a terrible after taste. I have ordered from here before but may take a break after tonight. Read more
OMG! Pizza and wings were delicious, the crust was perfect, just amazing! easy ordering online and ready so fast!! And the man... working tonight is super friendly! Couldn?t ask for anything more! Read more
This was a first experience for us, as we just moved into the area. I?d like to note that the guy on the phone, and in person,... was pleasant. Regarding the pizza, we have a mixed review. The pepperoni was honestly great. Solid crust, seasoning, and evencheesier than expected. 8/10. However, the buffalo chicken pizza was pretty rough. There was no buffalo sauce in sight, and infact it was weirdly sweet? It was also very, very wet, which was off putting. Lastly, though the chicken was juicy, it was sadlyflavorless.1/10. This is not meant to deter anyone from trying the place, but moreso for the owners to see and maybe improveupon. I personally plan on ordering from this location again and hope to see an improved buff chicken! Read more
I'm originally from the Philly/South Jersey are and I've been looking for exactly this type of pizza here in Roc and finally... found it! Everything about this pizza reminds me of carefree days on the Wildwood boardwalk. The crust tasted (and was textured)a lot like the Italian rolls my Italian grandmother used to get from the bakery in South Philly. If you know then you know. Read more