Reviews for Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Roberts, ID
Pleasantly surprised at finding this delicious pizza place on our way from Rexburg back to Boise. It is now one of my son's... favorite pizza places. We will make sure to eat here again if we are driving through in the future! Read more
I was pretty impressed with the pizza and bread sticks. Hands down authentic NY thin crust style pizza. So glad I stopped here... to grab a pizza pie in my travels! Reminded me of Tony's there in the heart of NYC. I'll be adding this place in my favoritefolder to stop in my travels for pizza. Read more
Absolutely awesome. I'm a long haul trucker and was passing through - called in an order for a pepperoni pie super well done... (almost burnt) and extra crispy crust. They nailed it spot on, delicious. And the anti-pasta salad was just the perfectcompliment. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED, and that coming from a native NY'r. As a side note, if you're in a big truck, there's a dirtlot right on IA48 you can park and walk across the street to pick up your order. Read more
Vestpian and cheesy bread was delicious! Stopped in on our way through on the interstate. Did not disappoint. Thin crust with... the right amount of greasy! Yum! Read more
Not impressed. Very greasy pizza, flavor was ok, but the employee that cashed us out had flour/dough on their hands and then... went immediately back to cooking after taking our money. We did not get sick, but left wondering if were going to later thatevening. Read more
I had ordered 4 pizzas and 1 of my orders was messed up and wasn't even what I had ordered. We called in and they told us that... we had to bring in all four of our pizzas for them to fix one of them. The pizzas had no crust under the toppings. The crust onthe end was terrible and was wrapped underneath the plate it's on so the crust got burnt. There was hardly any pepperonis on thepizzas as well and that's how it always is. The pizzas are getting crappier and crappier everytime I order from them. Theservice in that place is getting worse and I think they need to hire people that actually know how to work instead of all theseteens that don't know what to do. Read more
Really good NY style pizza. Excellent crust and generous toppings. There are several locations now around east Idaho. This... location is quite small with a small table for two indoors and a table outside. A bench is provided at the order counter towait for your order. Friendly staff. Read more
Even if you want pizza in Idaho Falls, skip it and take the drive to Lucy's. Lucy's is the kind of authentic place everyone... always demands yet can hardly find l. Real hand-tossed pizza crust, top shelf fresh ingredients, REAL mushrooms, fresh onionsand peppers and real cheese. This is the kind of place everyone needs to visit so they don't go out of business. It is hard tobelieve such a one horse town can have such a gem of a pizza parlor! Nothing fancy for dine in, but you can stay if you like.Lucy's is what all great pizza joints should be like. Oh, and the gas station out on the highway, it had Modelo Dark beer. Nojoke. From now on I'm stopping in Roberts to have beer and the best pizza in the entire three state region! Read more