Reviews for Black Star Pirate BBQ in Richmond, CA
Extra star for live music and all the Burning Man art nearby. Kudos for all the veggie options for a BBQ place, unfortunately... the veggie platter was room temperature. It wouldn't be hard to microwave the food to give the illusion of freshness. A friendsaid the Potebello on cheese grits was good, so order that if vegetarian. Honestly, it is strange and uncomfortable for a 1sttime visitor to have to order the food when you walk in the door, and you can't even see the menu very well while waiting inline. Get there early on weekends because the line to order/walk in the door can have 30 people in it. Also it is dog friendly.Over all good ambiance and worth a trip, but the cold food was a disappointment. Read more
Not a bad place to spend an afternoon. We made the trek out here on a recommendation, and enjoyed the food. 3 meat and 3 side... combo and a few drinks fed 2adults and a teenager, but might have been more suited to just 2 adults. Burnt tips were excellent. It seemed a bit light on the pirate theme, but we still had fun. Dog friendly with outdoor seating. Read more
You can easily split a 2, 3, or 4 meat plate between as many people and just add a side or two and dessert. Wonderful decor,... nice little adventure drive to get there, way off the beaten path. Great waterfront view. Cool art around. Live music. Can?tbeat a couple hours spent here. Read more
Food was excellent here! Must try the trip tip, coleslaw, and beans!! They had live music with great melody. It was a very... inviting and chill atmosphere. Servers are making you feel comfortable with where everything is and how it works and quick toserve and clean up. Nice access to a small beach with seating and a place to play. We would definitely return! ????? Read more
This is a totally unique place!!! Hard to believe that you are in the Bay Area. The grounds are amazing. Views of yachts and... houseboats from dining area. We loved our food, and there was a large band singing music from the 60s and 70s that kept ussinging along... You will be surprised at the large Burning Man sized sculptures. I definitely took lots of pics!!! Read more
We had high hopes. The place has great reviews, and is almost as close to the middle of nowhere for the Bay Area. The views are... great too. Now on to the food. It was below average. I've had BBQ from all over. We ordered the 3 meat plate - Ribs, Brisket,Burnt Ends. The tray arrived with sauce poured all over. My preference is on the side so I can decide how much I want. The ribswere pretty good. The brisket was so-so - not quite moist enough, and some odd fat strings (maybe we got an unlucky cut). Theburnt ends were very odd. I'd expect crispy/burnt meat from the smoker. What we got felt like lightly smoked tri-tip that wasthen pan fried. It was tough, and just tasted like tough smokey steak. Only 1 out of 3 was a winner on the meat side. The sideswere all great - Mac, Coleslaw, Beans. The biscuits were absolutely delicious. The seating is very bohemian - quirky, butsufficient. The service was great - the staff were friendly and efficient. The price was too much in all honesty. 2 adults, 1 6year old - sharing a 3 meat plate, 3 biscuits, iced tea and a Sprite for $97 inc. a standard tip. I wanted to love it, but don'tthink we'll be back... Even though it does have a quirky draw to the place. The main show - the meat - aside from the ribs wasnot good enough. Read more
In an adventurous mood, we set out for the day intending to find visit Black Star Pirate BBQ. Not really knowing what to expect,... we were pleasantly surprised by the beautiful and vast views on the drive in. Since it's located a bit off the beaten path, Iwould recommend visiting for the first time when you aren't in a rush. The parking area is mostly dirt, so it becomes muddyduring the wet season. Wearing the right kind of shoes will allow you the best opportunity to explore unencumbered. The areasurrounding the parking has numerous large and oversized metal and mixed media sculptures. Kids love to explore these andpotentially see some local goats as well. The restaurant itself is easy to find since it frequently features love music. Thedecor is rustic and sort of mismatched in a pleasantly inviting way. You are greeted at the entrance by a host who answersquestions and takes your order. The seating is open and both kid and dog friendly. At times, the larger tables can also becommunal if all parties are open to that. The central covered patio also has outdoor heaters for nights and cooler days.Overall, Black Star provides a friendly and welcoming environment. Imagine a large BBQ party at relatives that you haven't seenin while. The portions were good and food was very tasty. We tried three meats: ribs, pulled pork and brisket. We would orderall three again but my favorite was the brisket-- something worth fighting over the last bite! Even in sub 50 degree weather, weenjoyed the food, music and outdoor setting until after the sun went down. We are sure to return again and again! Read more
Wow, what a funky, cool place this is. Glad I discovered it before it closes. Good food and drink, live music, burning ???? man... art ???? and a lovely spot on the bay at point San Pablo. We spent the whole afternoon here recently, which is really easy to dowith all they offer. This is a great spot for a party or gathering. Plenty of room and parking and definitely off the beatenpath. Can't imagine what will become of this place after the restaurant closes ????. Love to go back at some point, will see? Read more