Reviews for Lehman's Supper Club in Rice Lake, WI
For special occasions this is the place to go!!! The whole experience was perfect. From reservation to final bill was spot on!.... Was a farewell dinner for my stepson and girlfriend who were moving to Oregon. When they all came out to sing " happy trails toyou" OMG it was perfect even though there no dry eyes by anyone at the table,it was best experience! Highly recommend!!!!! Read more
Family owned for generations. A warm and friendly ambiance. Small town hospitality and welcoming, professional staff. Broad... selection of food and drink with pricing comparable to other restaurants which satisfy my expectations. Very much worth the fiveminutes required to exit highway 53 in order to drive over to the place. Read more
We arrived at 6:06 for our 6:15 reservation, and we were promptly seated, we were not seated in the main dining room as... requested, but rather a side room that had the ambiance of a banquet hall including a worn torn room divider. Only one otherparty was ever seated back there the entire time we were there. The relish, drink orders, salad and soup service was good. Thendespite being served by two waitresses, we were a party of twelve by the way, we did not get our meal until 8:00 pm. The waitstaff must have known there was a problem because they were out of our area and never checked with us once in 40 minutes. No oneever asked if we wanted a second drink etc. When we did see them, they brought complimentary popovers, but by then none of uswere even hungry. The food was good when it finally came, but did not make up for the extremely poor service. The bill wasalmost $500 and we left 20% for the wait staff despite the bad service. So we dropped nearly $600 for that kind of treatment. Wewere in the area for vacation, so our only guess for the poor treatment is they were more concerned with their regulars. Shameon you Lehmans. Read more
Excellent dining !! Servers Heidi ( bartender ) Paula ( waitress ) are the ones we most are served by and always a pleasure.... Autumn is so much fun makes every time a wonderful experience. Wish her well on her schooling & look forward to seeing her &others during the holidays !!! These 3 employees are shining stars that represent Lehmans well. Nice job ladies ! And specialthank you to the chefs & kitchen help for amazing meals! Read more
Wow. Fantastic meal and our server Bree did an awesome job. You are so lucky to have her. We moved away from Rice Lake years ago... so this is the first time in 25 yrs that we've been back. As in the past we were not disappointed. Thank you.Sincerely theSkougs Read more
Husband & I traveled from Janesville to treat our very good old friends from Chetek, to dinner for their Christmas gift. ... Everything was wonderful except for 2 things: one, they were not able to make a cocktail for me (I believe the name of it had"Black Forest" in it), but was still charged for the cocktail & two, the size of the brie appetizer was small. You only get awedge (1/4 wheel) of brie. I was expecting a wheel of brie baked in phyllo dough. We ordered 2 small prime rib dinners, 2medium prime rib dinners with the brie appetizer. Dinner included a salad & a side (we chose Lyonaise potatoes). We also paidextra for the very highly reviewed French Onion soup. Additionally, they provided a nice relish tray with fresh carrots, greenonions, radishes, cantaloupe, strawberries, watermelon & pineapple before the meal and 4 dinner rolls with the meal. Dinner &drink total with tip was ~ $325. Service was prompt. Very nicely decorated for the holidays. We were one of the firstcustomers for a Saturday evening so we lucky enough to sit by the fireplace. Read more
The finest in Supper Club dinning experiences. From beginning to end this was a fantastic Supper Club. The ambiance, the... service, the food, everything about this fine establishment screams classy Supper Club. We were greeted immediately, seatedimmediately and the service just kept getting better from there. We will definitely be going back and soon and when we do, I amrequesting the bar because it has quiet, tucked away booths and the lights are dimmed for an even more amazing effect. I highlyrecommend this Supper Club, I swear you will not be disappointed. Read more
The recommendation to stop in Lehman?s for French Onion was spot on! The soup was full of flavor, not salty, topped with a... golden Ai Gratin cheese, the French bread was warm and had a nice crisp crust too. Paula was my server and was pleasant,professional, and the service was quick. I look forward to coming back for a full meal soon. Ps, note I received plenty ofbutter! Read more