Reviews for Massey's Pizza - Reynoldsburg in Reynoldsburg, OH
Ordered two cauliflower crust pizzas. Both crusts were burned. Manager asked me to bring them back to be remade or tale half... off on next purchase. If they are #1 in Columbus, why would they let those burned pizzas out of their store? Quality controlwasn't operating. Also had trouble with their app. Read more
Ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom on 9/02/2022. Had one a while back and wasn?t satisfied so thought we would give it... another try. Took a coupon for $3.00 off and we?re told we couldn?t use it unless we ordered the pizza and the Stromboli. Couponsaid pizza or Stromboli. Also the pizza was burned. Large pep and mushroom $21.24. Won?t be back. Read more
Very nice staff. I didn't enjoy the sauce or meat on the ???? pizza. However, I appreciate the opportunity to try a new ????.... Thanks ???? Read more
Ordered a taco pizza tonight. It was 120 mins to arrive compared to 45 as promised. Not a big thing, I know places are short... handed. When the pizza arrived it weighed like 10lbs. Normally people complain that there aren't enough toppings. This pizza waspiled HIGH with toppings. The thing about that is, this is a super thin crust pizza. The crust can not handle a inch or more oftoppings. They cook this pizza with a inch of toppings on it the same about of time as a pizza with one topping. Therefore, thepizza was undercook, and not warm under all the toppings and the cheese not melted. Making the pizza a big pile of MUSH!!!! Eveneating it with a fork, was totally disgusting!!! We ate two pieces and called it quits! $26.00 for a 12 pizza down the drain!!!! Read more
You'd have to drive 130 miles to get better gluten free pizza; crispy, crunchy, delicious, not the least bit chewy. You... complete me. Edit:owner's reply makes me want a pizza.... Mmmmmmmm. Read more
Massey's never fails to impress anyone I take there. This trip included my son and one of his friends. We all enjoyed the... pizza, and this is one of the rare places I get a box to take extra food home. The price is up there, but the quantity oftoppings makes that seem less painful. We live 2 hours away and still stop here on trips into the city. Read more
Pizza good as always! But come on?!?! Really? Wings are a complete and utter rip off, $10.00 for 8 pieces of popcorn chicken.... Better value in a McNugget Read more
I ordered a Sicilian deep dish,wings,and a pblt. My mom said the pblt looked burnt. The deep dish was o.k. but the wings were... HORRIBLE!!!! THEY SMELLED AND TASTED LIKED LIGHTER FLUID. ( I don't know what lighter fluid tastes like.) But the smell was likelighter fluid. And they were just plain nasty!!! I ordered mild ..I have no idea where the sauce was???????????????????. I spent44$ it was a waste!! I don't mind paying that for something that was actually good. But it wasn't worth it. Especially thewings. What a disappointment. Read more