Reviews for Righteous Slice in Rexburg, ID
Got one of their New York style pizzas, and it was a phenomenal experience. A delightful blend of flavors that gave a new... experience with each bite. By far the best pizza in town Read more
Awesome firewood Pizza, loved the margarita, God Father and the NY Cheese Pizza!! You should try this place.
First time here and I LOVED it!!! The atmosphere was really fun, though it was a bit loud (but it was a packed Friday night, so... that's to be expected haha) Their shakes are AMAZING (and decently priced to boot!) I got the Nutella Brownie and it waseverything I hoped for and more. My roommate got the Raspberries N Cream with the housemade raspberry sauce, and it definitelyhit the mark! It's now on my bucket list to try every flavor of shake that they have ???? Their pizza is good too, and I'mlooking forward to trying more of them! Their pizza crust is super satisfying and their red sauce is lighter than others, butit's bursting with flavor. The specific pizza I tried was a little "soggy" because of all the toppings/artichokes and its athinner pizza in the middle, but it still tasted amazing. Their cheesy garlic bread was packed with flavor as well, though therewas a flavor that my roommate and I couldn't quite put our finger on that was a bit "off". Don't get me wrong it was DELICIOUS,but I probably couldn't eat a lot of it in one sitting. Overall it was a fun experience, the staff was friendly, and themenu+food was incredible. Definitely worth the little extra cash, and you can bet I will be back ???? Read more
This place is amazing! I love the pizza here it is so fresh with all their ingredients and they offer some unique pizzas. The... flavor is amazing. The place is a super cool environment as well. Definitely check this place out. Read more
Righteous slice is the best freaking pizza in Idaho. It?s brick oven cooked with actual fire and the pizzas are super creative.... The bee sting is my favorite pizza to get but you can?t go wrong with any of their menu options. The owner has a passion for hispizza and his customers. I?ve eaten here probably over 15 times and I?ve never been disappointed. It?s a great date place too!Break away from the chains of chain restaurants and get yourself some really amazing food. Read more
This was my first time getting a pizza from Righteous Slice, other times I had gotten shakes, and the pizza was really good. I... have tried their pizza before and I enjoyed it but it was a bit old so it wasn't as fresh. However, having the pizza fresh andin the restaurant was a whole new experience! It was delicious and it filled me up perfectly. I definitely will come again. Read more
We drove an hour to get here and it was totally worth it. The staff was super friendly and nice. They helped us order after... hearing it was our first time. The salad was HUGE and we split it. The strawberries on it were perfect and it was so fresh anddelicious. We each got the same pizza but changed out the cheese. My daughter got the shredded and I got the freshmozzarella. They told us that the fresh mozzarella is made right there. We did a taste test and both were actuallyoutstanding. The food comes out in five minutes so nobody goes hungry long. Great value, amazing people, and lovely location. Werecommend it!!! Read more
This place kills it! We come a couple times per month and have only ever ordered a Neapolitan styled pizza, however we branches... out (yes we just got cheese and pep) and it was awesome. The New York style is definitely something worth ordering and waitingfor! Everything is fresh and made with love. The environment is fun and inviting. I will for sure be buying more New York Stylepizza in the future! 10 out of 10 Read more