Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Rexburg, ID
We love the BBQ Hawaiian pizza! They're fast with getting your order out, and you can see exactly what they're doing the whole... time. Read more
The Hawaiian BBQ is amazing! We get two every time we go! They have fast service even when you order at the counter.
Came in and asked what their soy free options were. She simply said she didn?t know. I asked if she had an allergen menu and she... said they didn?t have one. This is incredibly problematic considering that allergies can be a life threatening issue. I ended upleaving with the complete lack of awareness. Very disappointing as I love Papa Johns but my husband has a soy allergy. Read more
I like Papa Johns in general and this one's pizza is fine but just a heads up to anyone that cares, no contact is a lie. If you... order delivery and select no contact they'll ignore it and if you don't answer the door they'll just...take your pizza back.Whether or not I'll get my money back is still pending. Read more
It was really good! Although it did take 30 minutes for 1 order of garlic knots. It?s an excellent place to eat, just know you... might be there for a while. Read more
Papa John?s makes good pizza. I?ve eaten a lot of it, but this location doesn?t seem to put much effort into their pizzas. They... often miss sauces and on our latest order they barely put enough cheese on and the pizza was burnt and sloppy. We payed extra to?papa size? the pizza and it looked like they just added more dough and not anything else. Read more
Papa Johns already has the best pizza BY FAR and this location just makes it even better. They are always so quick to get my... order finished and the staff is always very friendly especially the night manager Sam, she needs a raise for how great of workshe does. My pizza is always done in a timely manner and tastes great. Read more
The pizza is literally all burnt, I'm surprised they even served it and let it out the door