Reviews for Libby Hill Seafood Restaurants in Reidsville, NC
Food was great. It was nice to still have a Libby Hill Seafood Restaurant around. So many have closed. Fond memories. My... first job as a teenager was at a Libby Hill Restaurant. Read more
Had to send our steaks back 30 times & they still didn't get them cooked med well. The steaks were tasteless. No seasoning or... flavor. The sweet potatoes were not cooked done. We paid ove $60.00 for our steak dinner. $60.00!!!!!!!! Read more
Food & service were both excellent! It had been a long time since we had been to a Libby Hill restaurant but the food was... exactly what we remembered and the employees made us feel welcomed. The building was the only thing lacking. Everything wasclean, but some maintenance was needed inside. Some of the ceiling tiles need to be replaced badly due to past leaks. Not ahuge deal, but it would make you feel better about eating there if they were replaced to know that they take care of theirsimple maintenance. Overall, we were extremely happy with our experience and we do plan on going back soon. Read more
Will never spend another dime here, food was very disappointing compared to what it used to be, portions were small, we called... in the order and picked it up, most of the $40 I spent went in the trash once we got home, never again! Read more
We came in tonight ordered our food over the phone I specifically told the girl EXACTLY what I wanted, waited in line, got to... the window, used a card and was up charged $1.28 ? We just spent $32....Theirs a little sign on the window that says it...it'sdark out there so of course we can't see it. We get down the hill and they gave us the wrong shrimp. We ordered fantail. I goback in. They're "out" of fantail shrimp...which shouldve been explained on the phone. The girl had lots of opportunity to tellme on the phone they didn't have that type of shrimp. They didn't give us the right condiments. We asked for ranch and bbq. Wegot a huge bag of mustard ??? PLEASE train these workers better. COMMUNICATING to your customers who've been there for 30 years& up. Smile. Be happier. This place is MOST DEFINITELY goin down hill !! They got kids running the show now smh DO BETTER. Read more
We eat here often. The orders are always correct. The food is always great. My only bother about this restaurant is the trash... outside, on the premises and on the border of the parking lot. Not a great curb appeal but good food none the less. Read more
This is a wonderful place to get some great seafood! I just loved the Calabash shrimp platter! The portions are fantastic and... the prices are great! I even bought some Libby Hill cocktail sauce to take home!! Bay Hill!! I wish I could give more than fivestars for this wonderful experience!!! Read more
I?m so disappointed with this place!!!! The waitress must have been new and when she was setting the second drink on our table... her tray got uneven and she spilt one of the drinks on my computer. I was frustrated, but had good faith it would be okay. Ipaid for our dinner, left a tip as usual. I then asked to speak to a Manager to let them know about the situation. I wasn?trude, demanding or asked for anything in return. The manager blamed it on my 15 year old daughter and said it wasn?t hisproblem. THE ABSOLUTE LEAST they could have done was pay for our meal considering they probably ruined my $1000 computer withmuch more valuable things on the computer. On top of that, I have no way of completing my proctored exam that was scheduled for11pm tonight. I?m disgusting with the attitude and compassion that was not shown. This definitely isn?t a business that caresabout their customers. I truly hope this or something worse doesn?t happens to anyone else at this establishment. Read more