Reviews for Old Piney Dell Restaurant in Red Lodge, MT
Amazing location beautiful scenery however, I ordered a medium rare steak. If that steak was medium rare I?d hate to see what... rare looks like. Probably all four hooves attached. It had good flavor but lost a bunch after the second time on the grill.Could have used a third time on the grill as well. I called to make a reservation and in the background I could hear ?theybetter be coming like right now?. Our waitress was very nice as well as the gentleman who was behind the bar. But some of theother staff were pretty rude. Read more
Very cozy classic fine dining. Food ranges from incredible to inedible, and the service is equally inconsistent. I've had some... truly delicious dinners here, but also experienced some catastrophes. At least it's never boring! Read more
Recently visited for a birthday party. Awesome location and a cool old building. I had ordered one entree and the wrong one was... brought out. Since I was with a large group and did not want everyone to wait, I kindly said I would eat it. Very salty and notmy favorite. Waitress was new and was nice but definitely a rookie! Read more
OMG! The whole experience was amazing. This is a reservation only establishment. Very cozy. From the minute you arrive, you know... you've made a great choice. The food...excellent! The staff was well prepared in their jobs Chef Barrie...thank you! Read more
The best quality food you can get in Red Lodge at the moment. Incredibly talented chefs, a great ever-changing menu, and high... prices that are 100% worth it. This is my go-to stop for every date-night or celebratory meal. Plus, they have a dining roomwith a great view of the creek! Beautiful atmosphere! Read more
For the amount of$$ you pay, I expected better quality of food and service. Twice through the buffet line and no fresh food.... Mashed potatoes dish was empty. Turkey was sparse and what was left was sitting in what look like water. What's Thanksgivingdinner without desert? Well didn't go near it. It looked like it had sat out all day and was crusty looking. Service wasdownright horrible. Asked for a glass of water and sat for 20 minutes and watch the waitress serve water to an empty table. Notonce did she make any kind of eye contact with us. Never will I eat there again. One shot and they blew it. Read more
I have eaten here on three different occasions and every time there have been new items on the menu and it is always delicious!... Cute little restaurant with the river running by (great photo opportunity!) Would recommend making reservations a head of time,especially for larger groups and not be in a hurry. Sit back, relax and enjoy the delicious food and scenery! Read more
The new chef does not seem to be ServSafe certified, but has knowledge of some foods. New staff is awesome without the rude... bartender gentleman and front hostess lady. Would recommend! Read more