Reviews for Red Moon in Put-In-Bay, OH
I ordered an espresso martini. I have had many in my day, and even make it myself often. When I received it, there were small... balls of chocolate floating aggressively throughout, and it tasted like watered down coffee with straight absolute vodka. I tooktwo sips and asked if they can just make it on the rocks with no chocolate pebbles. That one was palatable. The reasoning forone star is that the individual with the beard made me pay for the original martini in which again, I gave back after two sips!The total bill was $41 for three drinks 2 of which my mother and I drank and another I gave back! I did ask if they accidentlydidn\'t take one off, the man with the beard rudely claimed that it is against their policy to comp, especially when the drinkwas made correctly. I would have understood if I drank the whole thing, however two sips is far from that. The situation couldhave been avoided with simple common restaurant etiquette. Suppose not. Read more
Not a speak easy anymore. I have tried twice and the patrons were loud - easily overhearing the conversations all around.... Service was slow. Very disappointed on my second try at this ?speak easy? Read more
Very unique find. Clean. Great drink selection highly recommend
Amazing ambience, great menu, immersive decor. This place was awesome, albeit a little hard to find but totally worth it to... escape the crowds and loud noise. They also made my drink, a Tom Collins, correctly! It was my favorite part of my visit toput-in-bay! Read more
Would probably skip this place next time. The interior was cool but the bartenders were super busy and over worked. The Tom... Collins, while prepared nicely, had NO taste. Find this place by going out the back of the Roundhouse and immediately up somestreps on the right. Prices were on par for trendy speakeasy type craft cocktail bars. I Recommend not putting this in yourface. YMMV. Read more
They have an amazing hand crafted drink menu. But the atmosphere used to be much better when the bar tenders would shush people... and ask noisy groups to leave. Now it feels like any other loud noisy bar, just with better drinks. The decor is beautiful, butthe bar was understaffed just one tender and they could barely keep up with drinks both nights we came. It\'s still my favoritebar on the island but now it\'s just less special. Read more
I love this secret place in Put In Bay. It took a while to find it! They have the very best strawberry balsamic martini. I have... yet to find anything like it back home. What a gem of a place! Read more
I haven?t been there in a while, but I used to be a local for a few summers. I loved drinking here and even celebrated my 21st... there. Their creativeness with cocktails is only matched by the relaxing decor. The music is a plus too. Can?t wait to go back.If they?re still making the cinnamon apple whisky, make sure you try it. Read more