Reviews for Sella's Calzone & Pizza in Pullman, WA
I agree with some of the reviews. The pizza taste amazing, definitely something out of this world. BUT, the price for such... experience is steep! For what I paid, I could've gotten 4 pizzas, wings, and a soda at dominos. I don't think I'll be comingback cuz I'm broke but if you had the money then i definitely recommend trying it out once. Side note, the staff is veryfriendly too and it has a chill vibe to it. Read more
I ordered the Supreme calzone. Usually what I get is like a version of Jim Gaffigan's hot pocket jokes where it either comes... with a frozen center, or boiling lava hot! This one came almost perfect. It really just needed another minute to finish cookingthe dough and melting the cheese, but I was in a hurry and didn't mind. If that happens to you, just send it back to finishcooking. They won't mind at all. You'll just need to be a little wary if you're ordering takeout since you can't really check itbefore you leave. Speaking of time, the calzone was delivered just 10 minutes after ordering. Read more
The pizza was great and delicious. Service was excellent and fast even during the busy time. I enjoyed the crayons and placemats... to draw, nice touch. I give it 4 stars because the food and drinks are a tad pricey. Read more
The best pizza and calzone I?ve ever had. Incredibly overpriced and No AC. But staff was nice and place was clean enough. Small... bathrooms and could?ve used a cleaning but again pizza was amazing. The flaws are consistent with a college area joint. A largepizza, 1 calzone and 2 fountain drinks: $75 bucks. Yep. Overpriced? Yes. Worth it? Yes. I?ll be flying back to Pullman just forthis spot! Read more
DELICIOUS!!! One of my favorite hometown spots and is always so yummy!
7/25/2021 (5 Stars) We have not been here in 10 years. We planned part of our 4 day trip specifically to have lunch here - to... eat one of the best calzones around. Our daughter went to WSU, neither us did. Last time we were here was when she graduated. We were not disappointed!! Glad we made the stop!! Read more
I critique pizza heavily based on style, taste, quality and quantity 1. The style is most similar to a pan pizza w/o added oil... onto the crust. The crust is thick and hearty. 2. The taste is a 7/10, not the best cheese quality (typical mozzarella cheesefrom most mediocre American pizza chains). The marinara sauce is light with a hint of sweet tomato. You taste a lot of cheeseand dough ( for pan pizza and extra cheese type pizza lovers) 3. Quality is mediocre nothing outstanding, slightly better thanyour typicall fast food pizza. 4. The price/quantity ratio is good for a restaurant pizza. Nothing fancy, just cheese for firsttime grading. The 12" is equivalent to a 14" at a fast food pizza chain. You will feel the weight if you grab the box to go.$10-12" FINAL THOUGHTS: The dough is a thick fluffy crust so if you're not a fan of thick dough, this pizza is not your style.The cheese amount is equivalent to adding extra cheese at fast food pizza chains. The cheese/crust ratio is fine since the thickcrust compensates; although, my only complaint is not enough marinara sauce, you taste cheese/dough but not enough marinara tocompensate. As a pizza maker I will clarify: this pizza may taste raw for some people cause of the thick dough crust but that isnot the case. Thick dough tends to change texture as it's cooled down with marinara sauce on top. If you have had house madethick crust you know what I mean, not your typicall pizza hut pan crust. Read more
We love Sella?s!! Absolutely best pizza around. And for the price? Such a great deal. I live a bit out of town and have thought... about ordering pizzas not baked so I could freeze and bake when I?m not feeling like driving in cause it?s that good! Read more