Reviews for Nassau Street Seafood & Produce Co. in Princeton, NJ

I shop here every single month. I spend hundreds of dollars on amazing fish, in particular Chilean Seabass and halibut and... shrimp. I also love the produce! but tonight I bought 10 shrimp to serve alongside some Chilean Seabass and it was horrible. Ithas like chemical smell before I cooked it and after I cooked it and served it it smelled bizarrely like plastic. No one couldeat it. I am usually the happiest customer so I am particularly baffled and disappointed that you would sell this product. Ofcourse I demand a full refund and please?get your act together. Read more

Heard they had lobster rolls. Went for a bite with my girlfriend and got 2 rolls. Came to $53 so we thought they would be big.... They were smaller than the palm of our hands and did not taste fresh. At least it came with french fries Will not be returning. Read more

We ordered half a dozen oysters for pickup (along with steamed lobster and a few other things) and the oysters were sitting in... water and had lost all their liquor/flavor. It was a bit disappointing. Lobster was decent. Read more

Customer Service wasn't very good. I went in today to get Chilean Sea Bass, which was extremely overpriced, $49lb. First, the... owner seemed like he didn't want to service me, and then seemed annoyed that I requested something additional. I called beforecoming and the person who answered seemed very nice but when I got there it was a totally different story.. I haven't triedthe fish yet. It did look very fresh but due to the unfriendly environment THAT I ENCOUNTERED. I will not be returning..Iwon't hold my breathe for a response from the owner. Read more

A true Princeton gem. Very helpful nice guys, been going there for lunch for years. The fish selection and quality is amazing,... you'd think you were on the coast or something. I typically get lunch here, they have daily specials in the $9-14 dollar range,fish sandwiches or such with fries, along with a collection of salads, soups, etc. Fridays are excellent lobster roll specials(and weekends). They will also quickly grill fish you buy, which is a great way to make a heart-healthy dinner very easily. Read more

This place is exceptional. There's a reason they have almost a perfect rating here. The selection of seafood is amazing, and... everything is superb quality and always fresh. Moreover, the guys who work here really know their fish. You can ask them aboutany piece of fish in the place, they'll tell you what it's like, where it's from, and even the best way to cook it. Some days Ijust walk in and say "what's good today?" and they'll recommend 4 or 5 things that stand out. But honestly, you could walk inhere and blindly point at something behind the counter and you know it's gonna be great. They also supply the fish for BluePoint Grill next door, same owners I believe, so if you've been there (it's amazing too) that's the level of quality fish youcan expect here. Absolute top shelf stuff. Read more

Small walk-in Seafood place with fabulous lunch items. You can eat outside next door outside at Bluepoint grill. Ceviche Tacos... are the best! Just as you imagined they should be. Fresh and healthy! Read more

Excellent seafood and customer service. Very knowledgeable staff. Best fish tacos around!