Reviews for The Settlement Kitchen + Craft Tavern in Priest River, ID

Driving by this old town and the new age store front catches our eyes. Stopped for their happy hour which offered draft beers... at $3 to $5. We sit outside and enjoyed an adault mac & cheese plus a good snack salad. The waiter is as friendly as if we arefrequent customers. A wonderful surprise passing by priest falls. Read more

This is our fourth time at the settlement kitchen. We made reservations and were able to sit right away. The place was packed at... 7:00 p.m. on a Saturday. My wife and my neighbor both had the burrata raviolis and I can tell you that the sauce was fantastic.I had the mac and cheese for adults with pulled pork for my second time. My dinner was plentiful and delicious and I broughthalf home for dinner tonight. The wife and I had two drinks each and two meals and side dishes for 75 bucks. Service was goodand waitress was friendly and it was nice to watch college football game on the TVs that are spread out over the facility. Ihave in-laws coming to town late October and we're going to go back there again. Read more

I am going to give this three starts for a couple of reasons. We ordered appetizer but we never got it. That was the first... mistake. Second the drinks refresh rate was on the very slow side. We had a special request on Broccoli to cook it longer tomake it soft due to a chewing problem. Still came out normal to almost raw. I had the mature max with no changes and it wasreally good. So i don?t know if it was a fluke in ordering or just pore back end. Would I come back. I would have to say yes. Read more

This was a really tasty restaurant recommended by friends. The cider I had was crisp and light ????, The cowboy burger was... delicious! The pickled jalapenos added the perfect amount of spice for this Texas gal! The artichoke crab dip we had as anappetizer was very tasty, as well. Read more

This is the third time we?ve eaten at The Settlement, and each time the food has been outstanding. We drive to Priest River just... to come here (about an hour?s drive from where we live), and so far we have not been disappointed. They were very busy today,but our server Michael was very attentive and made sure we were were well taken care of during the wait. I had the shrimp tacos,and my sister the Pressed Cuban, and both meals were perfect. (We also had the crab and artichoke dip prior, which they servedwith fresh fried pita chips and crudités, due to my gluten allergy). Just - seriously- the best food. Well worth the trip,every time. There is something for everyone here- gf, vegan, carnivores, and kids. Read more

We just stopped in for a quick lunch, and we are so GLAD! Service was great, and the food, you can tell, is all house made! We... shared fish tacos and pulled pork tacos, a couple of bevvies, and it was all great! Read more

100% honest review. I've been to this establishment several times now and patron this establishment before this person owned it.... I only ate at the previous establishment one time and both myself and my two business partners received food poisoning and neverreturned until a new owner and name appeared. I was very pleased aesthetically with the interior. The new owner has done atremendous job at making the place way more comfortable. Our first trip to the new restaurant was met with the friendliest ofstaff. We ordered our food, we received drinks all in a timely manner. The food was out of sight. Quality exceptional.Presentation outstanding. I must say that the fish tacos deserve an extra tortilla to keep them together better. The macaroniand cheese is the best in the world. At first I thought the price was a bit excessive but upon ordering and sampling I don'tthink they charge enough. A great cheese blend, mushrooms and bacon along with care and dedication make this dish one to be had.The beet salad, with candy cane beets and goat cheese is a dish that can never be replaced. We now order a beet salad andmacaroni and cheese every week to be picked up and brought home and enjoyed. The pictures above are the product we received andwe're taken at my own table. The product is just as fresh, hot and tasty as it is in the restaurant. 100% five stars in everyaspect. Read more

Delicious! Truly a huge surprise. This restaurant could be in a big city and have a huge following. I would recommend this place... to all of my friends and family. Best chicken wings (dill dry rub) we've ever eaten. We also tried the mac n cheese and buffaloburger. Clean restaurant and restrooms. Read more