Reviews for New York Strip Steakhouse And Deli in Preston, ID

SMALL TOWN - GREAT FOOD WHO: My siblings and I went for lunch. FOOD: I had an amazing meatball sandwich. Fun place to go,... as it's a small town so everyone knows each other. SERVICE: The owner herself took our order and made sure we were well takencare of. I WILL RETURN EVERY TIME I GO TO PRESTON Read more

Great food. Had the pastrami burger and it was just the right mix of ingredients. Quiet place to take someone special. Very... good service and the ladies served with a smile. I will go back. You should try it. Read more

Have been her 2x before and will not be coming here again!! Insanely over priced for what you get!! The sour sauce on the chips... is awful. The pit beef was old and smelled gross! I feel like people go here because not many other options available in town!!I will never go back again!! I'm literally at home sick only 10 minutes after eating this garbage!!! Read more

Got the new York strip.. um ordered the medium cooked steak, they were more on the rare side. They never really did check on... us.. plus it was over priced for the quality.. they should have been Ribeyes for the price. Read more

Just had the best lunch!! The Seattle Sandwich was amazing, salmon was absolutely delicious. Husband had the turkey, pastrami... and pit beef. Was delicious!! Will be back!! Read more

I love this place! The other day I was craving a Reuben dog but they were closed. Picked one up today and it was excellent! I... also love their brisket sandwiches, wings, fries, pretty much everything I've tried there is awesome! Definitely try it sometimesoon, you'll thank yourself! Read more

Food was excellent, service was slow but okay. We had a party of 8 + a highchair and tried to call ahead. They were surprised... when we walked in; no one had said anything. But the chicken piccata it fabulous and huge, and everyone else in our party wassatisfied with their food as well. Definitely good food. Read more

When I see mac and cheese on the menu I'm not exactly expecting it to be an actual full entree. This was a meal for sure. The... flavor combo lends to some interesting mixes with each bite allowing me to not get tired of the dish as I often do trying newplaces with big plates. Our server was wonderful and I can't wait to come try some of the other offers they have available. Read more