Reviews for Pizza Cottage in Powell, OH
Our first time ordering takeout from here and it was delicious. The pizza and garlic bread were hot and fresh! Friendly and... quick service will be back! Read more
This place is Amazing! The food is served Hot and Fresh. Hand made pizza's that make you want to keep going back. The sauces... are home made also. The booths have tv's in them so you won't miss your favorite shows while eating. This restaurant is spotless. Best pizza and extras ever. You can also get adult beverages. It's Family friendly. Read more
Cauliflower crust is amazing. They came to be part of the Nationwide Children's Hospital Golf Championship ProAm and I'm not... gluten sensitive or anything. I just wanted to try it. Wow. Really amazing! Texture is different sure but it tasted great andthe texture was really good. So good it caught me off guard! Thank you for being a part of the amazing event to raise money forpediatric cancer research and treatment. Than you for some REALLY great pizza!! Read more
We went to Pizza Cottage for dinner on a Friday night, about 8pm. The place had customers but was neither dead nor packed. We... were able to take a seat immediately, and a waitress was prompt to pick up our table. We ordered a kids personal pizza,spaghetti and breadstick, a small Sweet Thai Chicken pizza (for two) and an appetizer of Italian sausage with green peppers andonions with marinara. All of the food was excellent tasting, being decently unique for each of the items. I was particularlyimpressed with the appetizer, as it isn't something you generally see at a pizza shop. We ate fully, and to our heart's content.We will definitely be going back again. Read more
If this pizza is good, then the Little Caesars $5 hot & ready pizza is gourmet. The crust is like cardboard and the sauce was... nonexistent. I actually thought I was eating the cardboard the pizza sits on. This was my first and last time trying this pizza.If pizza today magazine as advertised on the side of their box is a real thing, you just lost all credibility. Scale of 1-10.This is a 1 and only a 1 because of the cheese. The wings were terrible as well, like they had been sitting on a buffet all day. Read more
Its not bad pizza, just very much not my favorite. $11 small (10") blk olive, mushroom. First, i like wedge slices where each... slice has a crist = handhold...these were tiny gooy squares. Second, the toppings were plentiful. At first glance I thoughtthe shrooms were fresh. The mouth feel and closer inspection reveals they are likely canned, just not the typical squishygrey-brown familiar "slices". Third, the sauce /seasoning. Pretty sure the seasoning (the green stuff) is all on top, not atall in the sauce. Thesauceday be "seasoned" meaning salt, pepper, and sugar, but otherwise, its just crushed tomatoes. Thereis a sour after taste. Just not my fav pie. Read more
Since Pizza Cottage took over the old Ruby Tuesday, we decided to finally give them a try. So, they darkened windows which is... actually nice. The decor is nice and the TV at certain tables is different but interesting. Our server was nice. He had togive us more time because only 1 of us had eaten there before. So, we got the jalapeño Poppers for me which were so good.Just a bit spicy but not that bad. I will definitely order them whenever we decide to go back. Potato skins were ordered butI didn't have any. I got the chicken Philly pizza ,no onions but kept the green pepper slices and mushrooms. It was reallygood! This will be my go to pizza for here. My son got a meat pizza which he loved. It was a nice dinner with really good food and good staff as well with no issues or mess up with our orders. All in all? This is a place worth looking into andtrying at least once. Read more
The pizza and cheesy garlic bread...delicious! Kim provided friendly and efficient tabke service. Unfortunately, Kim appeared... to be the only server in the restaurant and it took and hour to order and receive our food....totally ridiculous IMO, butdefinitely not Kim's fault! Not sure I would go back based on our experience, which is a shame because the thin crust pizza wasso good! Read more