Reviews for Brooklyn Pizza in Powell, OH
This guy can flat out make a pie. Up there in my top two pizzerias in the bus. Love the taste and the way the place is ran.
Recommended by a co-worker, I had the opportunity to try Brooklyn Pizza for the first time tonight. I lived/grew up in NYC, for... 30 years (LES!). I've lived in Columbus for the past 17 years and have not, as of yet, found any place that had pizza similar tothe NYC style pizza I grew up with. But, that changed tonight with my visit to Brooklyn Pizza. I ordered a small mushroom pizzaand was pleasantly surprised when I received it because it looked and smelled exactly like the NYC pizzas I grew up with. Andfrom the first bite it TASTED EXACTLY like the NYC pizzas of my past. I was amazed and very happy to finally find a pizza placewith authentic NYC pizza! I will definitely return to Brooklyn Pizza again and again. Read more
This is the best calzone I have ever had hands down! My daughter and I have come here several times specifically to get this... calzone. Their ricotta cheese is fluffy and to die for! Though this place isn't really intended for eating in they do have twotables out front, and is nice for some people watching on a nice day!! Read more
Easily one of the best pizza's I've ever had anywhere. Even visiting New York several times, never had pizza this good. Happy to... have it close to home. Read more
Fantastic pizza in Powell!! My family and I drive from Dublin to bring this back home. Some of the best pizza we?ve found since... we moved to CBUS. (Pro Tip) If you have to drive a bit back home ask them half bake the pizzas and not cut them so you canfinish cooking them at home. Attached pic is the Bianca. We added tomatoes and fresh cut basil to it. Soooo good. Read more
The absolute BEST pizza around. Its so nice just to be able to go in and grab a couple slices and a can of pop or get a pie to... go. Found my go-to Pizza place from now on. 10/10 Read more
Top notch pizza. Best New York pizza around. The staff is amazing! Nice to have a place you can get a whole pie or just a slice.... I've recommended Brooklyn to all my work friends and we always make a stop when in the area. Great size slices ????. Keepmaking the best pie around! Read more
Authentic NY style pizza. From the pizza by the slice to the can of coke, this is a must have if you?re in the area. Lunch... pictured here is under $10 which is nearly impossible to find nowadays. Read more