Reviews for Fyre 'N Ice in Portville, NY
I was excited to get there pizza and wings last night. Always been delicious. Well this time the wings were fatty and not cooked... and the pizza was tasteless. Came home and had to cook the wings for another half hour. Very disappointed. Will probably neveror again. Read more
First time here, just passing through. Very good brick oven pizza! The salad was fresh and boneless wings were flavorful and... baked just right. The atmosphere was nice, service was good, and they have ice cream! Read more
We ordered salads. I've always raved about the salads. Now, never again. I had the grilled chicken caeser. Chicken used to be... heated with the cheese and served on top. Everything was cold. I requested 2 caeser dressings. I got 2 half full. Then I wantedto take home my favorite cheesecake ice cream flavored with strawberry sauce. Instead of paying for a size container like weused to, its by the scoop. I blanking paid over 5 dollars for 3 scoops.I am never going back again.I never minded paying theprice for good food. But you really lowered the bars. Read more
(New Customer) Using the online menu pricing with tax our order should have been $30. Two pizzas cost over $50. (One topping... large and five topping gluten free) Was told new owners changed pricing but had not changed the menu online. I will never returnas a customer. Read more
I don't know if the cook didn't know how long to bake a pizza in a brick oven that is the best way to cook anything. It was... under cook and not very good and I don't know how he can mes it up. I was expecting a nice section of ice cream and I don'tthink they had 5 maybe 6. Read more
Solid 3.5. I'm not the biggest fan of the Hawaiian which is the 3 star to me. I am a very big fan of the cheese and pepperoni... which is the 4 star for me. My complaints about the Hawaiian were that it was too salty and way too thin and floppy of a crustto hold the toppings so it was a floppy mess. The pepperoni was great with zero complaints just a bit pricy for the size andsmall amount of cheese. Very nice place with pleasant staff and spotlessly clean seating area. I recommend them. Read more
Restaurant was great! We had mushroom pizza, wings, taco pizza, cheese breadsticks, ice cream sundaes. EVERYTHING was DELICIOUS.... I would highly recommend going. Service was top of the line and food was perfect. Read more
If I could I wouldn?t even give 1 star. We went in after a town parade ordered 1 palzone and a calzone. My palzone had half a... piece of meat, couple tiny pieces of onion and a little lettuce and globs of mayo for 12 dollars. Portville is a small town sucha shame! Read more