Reviews for DiMaggio's Trattoria in Port Washington, NY

Came here after a recommendation from a client. I had the cavatelli special and it couldn't have been any better. Also, had the... Oreo ice cream cake and that was also delicious. 4 out of 5 stars because the server was a little slow but still a greatexperience overall. Read more

Came here on a strong recommendation of a friend! Boy, was this place amazing! Authentic and everyone was so hospitable. I flew... in from LA for an event and this was the first stop. The food was spectacular! Take some time to see the town too. A realcharmer. Thank you Ed for your kindness! Read more

My wife and I had a wonderful time there celebrating our wedding anniversary. Eddie (one of the owners) and the staff treated us... so well we decided to leave a review. The food is very good too, specially the pasta. The cannoli (dessert) was phenomenal. Wehave only great things to say about this place. Give them a try! Read more

The atmosphere of the restaurant is romantic and cousy, the music was fitting, the service was fantastic, they were very... attentive. The food was great and my favorite were the homemade chocolate cake and the sangria. My husband favorite was the meatlasagna. Read more

DiMaggio?s Trattoria in Port Washington is a best kept secret in fine restaurant dining. The food is truly delicious, the... service is outstanding, & the ambiance is charming. Angelo, the owner of 43 years, is just so personable & welcoming. Whetherenjoying a dinner for two or a group of 15+, a terrific dining experience is a certainty! Highly recommended! David Dolan Read more

Found this hidden jewel because I couldn?t get in the restaurant I planned to visit. The Penne a la vodka turned out to be the... highlight of my day. It?s the best pasta I?ve ever had in the past 3 years and it definitely showed me the true form of comfortfood. I?ve never found myself smiling nonstop from the second pasta was served. Definitely recommend the pasta. Tiramisu was nottoo sweet, super moist and flavorful, perfect match with the extra foamy cappuccino served with perfect amount of groundcinnamon on top. Do not miss out on the dessert!! Read more

We just found this place for the 1st time on saturdy night but I am pretty sure it has been there forever. We received a warm... greeting from the chef and maitre D as we entered and were quickly seated, the food is absolutely amazing. Looks like they alsodo a booming take out business Read more

This restaurant was by far the BEST Italian food I have had in NYC and Long Island. The portions were perfect, the taste was... delicious, the timing of the food coming out amazing. From start to finish the experience we had was spot on perfect. The waitstaff and the owner were also very nice. We will definitely be coming back to DiMaggio's. Read more