Reviews for The Club - A Public Steakhouse in Port Jefferson, NY

The 42 oz porter is insane my wife and I had this and the garlic herb butter along with mashed potatoes and the broccoli and was... great drinks are awesome ambiance is great service is great five out of five Read more

A great choice for our search of water view restaurants here on LI. Great service...menu...wine list. Our "porterhouse" for two... was tender & very tasty. Didn't need to add anything or sauce to it. Kudos to everyone who made our dinner a very pleasantexperience. Read more

Went here for my own and my friend's birthdays and we were not disappointed! The food was absolutely delicious, all hot and... fresh. Steak was cooked perfectly. Wine service was great. Our waiter (sorry I forgot his name!) was very attentive and veryfriendly. Will definitely come back when the weather is nicer so we can sit outside. Read more

We came on vacation and we weren?t sure if they were public being in the country club. We called and made reservations and I... have to say my husband and I had the best steak and lamb we have ever had!!!! Awesome service too Read more

Steak was Ok. Burrata was the worst I ever had. Mozzarella was hard and prosciutto was dark brown and I questioned if it was... spoiled. Grounds also seemed a bit run down since I?ve last been here when it was Lombardi?s Read more

My steak wasn't cooked how I wanted. I dont think their food is worth the price but we enjoyed the view and our server was very... nice. We also had a Carpaccio (I didn't take a picture of it). Read more

Great service! Ty Annie! The Veal Tomahawk was to die for and my husband loved his Filet Mignon! The whole staff went above and... beyond and it was a pleasure celebrating our 16th wedding Anniversary where we got married (Formally Lombardi's on the Sound)The views alone are worth a visit. Read more

My wife and I went here for a date night. It was great. The cocktails were very good. The lobster/crab cake appetizer was the... star of the night. My steak was cooked perfectly but was a little under seasoned and not as juicy as I like. My wife said herhalibut was a little on the dry side too. The succotash was amazing, as were the polenta fries (wow, so good!). The service wasTOP NOTCH and we will definitely come back but probably order something slightly different. Read more