Reviews for Prohibition Port Jefferson in Port Jefferson, NY
I?ve had my eye on this place for a long time. I?m soooo glad I finally ate here . I went for The gusto and got a chicken... sandwich on a donut with sausage gravy .. I?m in love .. I have not felt this happy eating something so unhealthy in a long time. The place is small and quint . Cool vibes . Im walking out smiles ear to ear . Read more
If your following me like google. This is my fourth stop for the night. Tyler from Las Vegas and Keith from Queens were great... host. Read more
The food was A1, drink was tasty & the atmosphere was lively. I really liked the art all around the restaurant walls & allot of... natural light. Read more
First time coming and we cannot WAIT to come back. We put our name down after the hostess told us the wait would be about 30-40... minutes, we got called to sit down 30 minutes later and our waitress was super sweet! We ordered the Lets Dip appetizer withBuffalo Chicken Dip, Spin Dip and Queso - all 3 were VERY good. I got the steak sandwich and my boyfriend ordered the Fat BoyBurger. We couldn?t even finish everything. We took home the spin dip and our entrees. Our waitress even ran out to our carafter with extra chips! The staff and food both deserve more than 5 stars. Read more
I came here with friends that live in the area with high expectations, but was disappointed in the end. I did like the eccentric... vibe of the establishment itself. The hostess/waitress was very friendly and accommodating. She had rearranged seatingespecially for us which had a party of 8. The restaurant is tiny with not much seating. The menu looked promising, but I wasdisappointed with my order. I had ordered the Chicken and Waffles, which ended up being the blandest version of that dish I'veever had. I literally was just a chicken cutlet on top of a waffle, with a tiny bit of powdered sugar. Not worth anywhere nearwhat I had even paid for it. The other dish I am able to review from our order was the nachos. these were not that up to pareither. The cheese on the nachos was more of a cheese sauce which didn't allow for any toppings to stick and by the end thechips were so soggy, you had to finish them with a fork. One person in my party had the build your own quesadilla which actuallywas pretty decent. In conclusion, I probably will not eat here again, if I do I will spend more time to study the menu and askhow certain dishes are prepared. I hope this was helpful, please be sure to like and follow, It will be appreciated! Read more
My friend and I stopped in for dinner and drinks tonight. The drinks and food were delicious, service was pretty good as well.... We both enjoyed everything except the big daddy nachos. They are a $24 appetizer designed to be shared at the table. The servingof guacamole/salsa mixture was absurdly small, served in a plastic 4oz container. From the pictures you can see there was meltedcheese and some meat but there was a very superficial layer only. Nothing is below that top layer of cheese but a large amountof chips to be left at the end with nothing to eat them with. Honestly the nachos were really good but the price/plating isreally off. We thoroughly enjoyed every other part of our meal but most definitely do not recommend the nachos. Cocktails were10/10! Read more
Very cool little spot in the heart of the village. Creative craft cocktails and a solid, varied beer list. Was really impressed... by the half off happy hour menu on some drinks and small plates. Wouldn't expect that with the items on the small plates menu,ended up making a meal out of those. Will be visiting again for some large plates! Read more
Nice local pub. Bar is small but you can eat at it may save you time if it's busy. Had a burger wasn't anything special didn't... come with fries. The decor is simple trying to get that prohibition look. Bartender was friendly and helpful explaining the menuprices are average 2 people for lunch ran $65 . Worth a stop if you are in the area. Read more