Reviews for Old Fields Restaurant Port Jefferson in Port Jefferson, NY

First time here and definitely not our last. Everyone from the hostess to the waiter and everyone else were great and the food... was awesome. We had complained about the French onion soup from another restaurant and the waiter took it upon himself to bringus all out a cup of theirs to show us how the soup is done correctly (free of charge). That is going above and beyond. Keep upthe great work. Read more

This Establishment is extremely well run. They went out of their way to make my wife and I have an extremely pleasant time on... our anniversary dinner. The food was amazing, the wait staff even better… And the manager often came over to check in on us. Ihighly recommend this restaurant… Truly the best of the best Read more

22oz bone in rib eye and marinade skirts steak. Service was very friendly and quick. Food was good and very comfortable... atmosphere. Would definitely go back again. Read more

French onion soup was excellent. If a place has good french onion soup, that's a good start. My steak was cooked perfect, medium... rare, but my wife's was over done. However, after bringing it to the attention of our server, they cooked another one and it wasperfect for her. Everything was excellent, server was happy and energetic and her delivery was perfect. I would dine thereagain. This was my second time there. Read more

We came here for Mothers Day this year. I could say that the food was okay, the service on the other hand was EXCEPTIONAL! We... found something in my daughter's pasta that was not supposed be there, the management took it upon themselves to serve our partyof 6 ANY desert drink we wanted .. including alcoholic and they also bought out one of each and every desert on the menu! It wasgreat, More of a steak house tho. Read more

I just moved to port Jeff about 4 months ago and I order from OF about 4 times a week and it’s not because I’m trying to put... the owners family through college. THE FOOD IS JUST THAT AMAZING! EVERY TIME. You cannot beat that but the icing on the steak, Imean cake was their bend over backwards customer service. The attention to detail from the hostess to the chef is something Iwill not soon forget. I have only ordered delivery so far and the fact that they recognized just a name coming across a computermade me feel special. This isn’t a slow or unpopular place so for them to take appreciation in my support guaranteed them alife long customer :) I cannot wait to go in person bc the property looks beautiful too Read more

? Lisa - Fast, efficient awesome staff. The customers love their food. Their tucked away right off of Pt. Jeff. Main St. I just... found them. Wow, I have to check out their food. The atmosphere & setting is cozy & romantic. I can't wait to dine their. Theyhave outside dining areas too. Really Beautiful. So Nice! - Lisa Lichelle ???? Read more

This place is excellent! I’m writing this review after my fourth dinner in three years, and I can say that the quality of the... place and the food is excellent. I drove almost two hours from Brooklyn to have dinner here. Staff is friendly and professional.Food is really good: last time we had French onion soup that was superlative, then a burger and fish and chips, everything good,but in the past I tried the chicken, salmon and steak: good! Parking lot right in front the restaurant Read more