Reviews for Mamma Lilla Pizzeria & Restaurant in Port Charlotte, FL

Had the Mama Lilla gourmet pizza, it was quite delicious. They scratch make their own sausage & dang was it tasty!

Check the recent reviews they tell the true story. It use to be a five-star place not anymore. I had two Sicilian slices that... were definitely not good. I didn?t even finish both of them. Read more

Wanted to try this place. Saw a "coupon" on Local Flavor, so made the purchase. A couple weeks later, my husband and I went in... for lunch. He ordered pizza slices and I ordered a Philly cheesesteak. My sandwich was very dry, as the meat was over cooked,so I couldn't eat it with the bread. My husband's pizza slices came out Luke warm and also lacked flavor. When we went to pay,I showed the "waitress" our coupon and she became very rude, stating that they were no longer accepting "those". I triedexplaining that I had just purchased the deal and she became more adamant, saying they now had new owners who instructed her notto take them under any circumstances. A $30 lunch bill, for not good food, at a restaurant with a fraudulent owner. We shouldhave know when we walked in the door, as there was only one table with customers. Don't buy the "deal" and don't waste yourmoney on this place....bad business! Thanks Local Flavor for your support and making things right! Read more

The first time we ordered out we absolutely loved it, the 2nd time not so much, the sauce wasn't just bitter there was something... off about it I couldn't place my finger on. As a former kitchen worker I would have never let a plate go out without testing itand I can't imagine anyone is using this common practice. Business is measured by quality and your return customers. Read more

A friend and I shared a stuffed pan pizza. Quite simply one of the best pizzas I've eaten in quite some time. It was more like a... gigantic Stromboli than a pan pizza but it was superb. Two slices and I was completely filled. There were only four tablesseated the time we were there so the service was excellent, though it seems to me that our server, Emily, could handle whateverwas thrown at her. Anthony did a great job cooking and I heard other people talking about how good the food was. I definitelywill be going back Read more

I was in the mood for spaghetti and meatballs but I had to add the Grandma's Pizza as an appetizer. It was heavenly. The best... pizza I've had in a long time and like my grandma DiMaggio used to make. Everything was good including the salad, spaghetti andmeatballs with a nice big dollop of ricotta cheese. Companion had a pasta dish with a tomato cream sauce. I don't remember thedetails but that was delicious also. Friendly wonderful staff as well. Read more

Ordered lunch-meatball parm. Sandwich was burnt, skimpy on the parmigian. Meatballs had little flavor. Sauce was ?ok?. Best part... was DoirDash was very good and product was still hot! Read more

If you want authentic delicious pizza- this is the only place to go in the area. The Grandma Sicilian is to die for. The... garlic knots are transcendent. It?s the only place I?ll eat pizza. Read more