Reviews for Timoti's Seafood Shak in Ponte Vedra Beach, FL

Great place! Good prices and love all the options. The blackened shrimp basket is amazing! Its not the best seafood in town but... it?s definitely a great casual seafood spot in Nocatee. Read more

My GOTO for Fried fish "Fresh CATCH" at a fair price for perfectly fried fish. I always get the fresh catch basket. Mahi is my... Favorite so far. The Fresh Catch was not available both days I went this weekend. Bummer but that's ok as there are many otheroptions. So I had the Alaskan Flounder fried - Delicious!!! The Next day the delivery was late So they Fried me up some SALMON!I love it ! One of my favorites and not many places will do this. I always get the NEW England Clam Chowder as its one of thebest around. So tasty! Read more

We really love the food here.. well most of it lol. The ?catch of the day? was Cobia and it was grilled and seasoned very well.... I added fries and black bean salad. It comes with these amazing hushpuppies.. clearly my favorite in the area and the tartersauce is equally as bright. My hubby got the grilled shrimp .. these were smaller and not very many for the price we felt butstill tasty. He accompanied it with their fruit (an orange sliced ??) and it was not a whole lot of food but again..those hushpuppies! We also enjoy having an option of a brewed unsweet green tea.. it was very good! This is counter service andthe kid who took our order was very professional and cold answer our questions. They do bring the food out to you. The reason Iknocked of a star was because we triers everything tables.. both outside and inside.. and the were all dirty.. cleared off butlots of crumbs and garbage. They had an adequate amount of people and I did eventually see the young man who took our order walkaround and clean them but they were not busy and that needed to be addressed. They seem to wipe them as a whole .. so not happyI was cleaning my own table. But the food will keep bringing us back for sure.. Read more

Timoti?s Seafood Shak was great! The atmosphere was energetic with a sense of newness and we had the choice of dining inside or... enjoying a perfect Fall day outside. The food was a perfect compliment to what the atmosphere had to offer. Our food tastedgreat from the blackened Shrimp Basket to the blackened Chicken Strips basket to the Lobster Rolls and the nice thing about itall was we were able to enjoy great seafood without the long wait and sitting in a traditional seafood restaurant! We had agreat experience and wonderful food! Thanks Timoti?s Seafood Shak!!!! Read more

It was the first time we were at the famous Nocatee Town Center. My girlfriend suggested that we go to a seafood restaurant. ... When we saw the high rating on google, we decided to go to the ?Timoti?s Seafood Shak?. We ordered tacos and a seafood soup. They had two options for the soup. A cup for $4.99 + tax or a bowl for $6.99 + tax. Since I was a little hungry, I decided togo for the bowl. We were very surprised when we got our order, especially with the size of each serving. I couldn?t believe myeyes when I saw the so-called bowl of soup with mostly potato. I actually took it to the counter to double check it. Thecounter person was not very sure if it was a cup or the bowl. So, she called another person and confirmed that it was a bowlthat is about the same size of salt shaker. I am sure if Timoti is so bend on ripping of the customers, he could charge alittle more money and provide adequate quantity. Perhaps it is the rich in the neighborhood who cannot realize that they arebeing ripped off by Timoti with substandard food and unrealistic payment. Read more

Food was delicious but the service SUCKED. Our drinks took forever though there were only two people at the bar. Our food came... out before the drinks were ready? The waitress dropped something off my plate and promised to return with it but did not? I hadto go ask and then she acted like she didn?t even know why I was coming to her? will try another location, maybe, but not thisI?ve? Read more

Came here for lunch on June 16, 2022 and I am so glad this restaurant came up on my Google maps list as it was absolutely... delicious, a clean and bright restaurant, with super friendly and helpful staff. Everything is cooked to order and came out bothhot and fast. The portion sizes were huge, so you really do get a great value for the money, and you won't leave hungry! One ofthe surprising stars on the tray were the hush puppies... fried perfectly crisp and golden on the outside, and light fluffy andnot greasy at all on the inside. I also appreciated the unsweetened iced tea selections! Read more

Fresh seafood in a fast casual atmosphere, and the kids have a pirate ship to play in! Tried the snapper with chimmichirri sauce... and cucumber salad. So refreshing and delicious! Read more