Reviews for Goody's Deli in Pocatello, ID
We all have our hits and misses and today was definitely not a hit for me. My wife and have been coming to goody?s for a few... years now. The food is pretty good for the most part. Today we ordered a personal pizza, Ruben sandwich, and some breadsticks. We were first in line and then a bunch of people came in behind us. We ordered our food and sat down. We waited for almost 50minutes, while in the meantime watching every person who ordered after us get their food! My wife finally went and asked them ifour tickets had been misplaced or something since it was taking so long. The lady just said it would be out super soon. We thenwaited another 10-15 minutes before we got it at our table. When the food arrived everything tasted pretty good except for thecheese breadstick?s. They were super dry and crusty. The Ruben on the other hand had me scratching my head. ITS NOT A RUBEN!!!They basically made me a Ruben breadstick pizza! It was still good but not what I was expecting. I?ll leave a picture of it soy?all can see!???? I definitely won?t get it again tho. The reason I?m not giving this place a one star, is because I?ve beenhere before and it?s usually decent. Hoping next time is better ???????? Read more
I've been here over 10 years and FINALLY went to Goody's. Don't ask me why. I can't tell you a good enough reason I had not. I... finally went today and I'm so grateful I did. OMG!! Had a salad, which I will now forever compare to any other salad I ever eatagain! So Freaking good!! EVERY bite had something delicious.... you can add anything except the kitchen sink on it for Free!It wasn't just a boring salad you have to search around to find a tomato to add to the bite. There was NO searching involved. Give it a 10 out of 10. Then I had a pizza bomb. The breading alone reminded me of a time long ago when restaurants actuallycared about the taste of their breading. Garlicky and buttery... Mixed with your choice of whatever....mine was the Hawaiianwith Jalapenos. Not only did the jalapenos burn like they should and add that extra flavor but the combination of the tastybreading and all the extras inside reminded me of a Jersey Calzone I ate years ago and dream of often. To top it off...I hadthe coldest draft beer I have ever had. I needed it after that pizza bomb!! I can't believe I deprived myself of this for solong. What. A. Dummy. Don't be a dummy... try it out. You won't be disappointed!! Read more
Great place for subs and pizza. My sub was so delicious! I got The Super since it was on special, and I'm glad I did. There are... a ton of veggies and other toppings, and it tastes so good. Beats the big franchises, if you ask me. Try it! Read more
I was just passing through town and I stopped in for a bite to eat and holy cow! this sub I think was the best sub I've had in... years. I got the regular spicy italian with a side salad, and it came out to less than 10$ Incredible Value! the sandwich wasmade with care, and these red peppers that were just to die for! If you ever go, and you like peppers with a little kick, askfor the red peppers, they took this sandwich from a 10 to an 11! Read more
Love this place! We always hang out in the other side where the bar is. It?s like Cheers! They say hello to you by name when you... walk in here (if you?ve been a few times). It?s a popular local hang out. Amazing specials and happy hour prices! Free cheesebread sticks during happy hour! SO good! Small local bands play here and they have very popular trivia nights. Popular hang outfor ISU employees/staff/students. Family friendly on the bar side until 10pm most nights (when restaurant closes). Read more
**update** I have reduced my rating. I went again today 5/21/2022. We had over half a pizza left and we're told we had to PAY... for a box or take a PIZZA home in foil. Something about a cardboard shortage and they ran out of boxes one time so now theycharge. I understand charging extra for takeout orders (most.placed do now) but to eat there and be charged to take homeleftovers. I try to keep my business to local shops but after frequenting for 22years, I am done. $10 for a small pizza and the to have to pay additional to take the rest. If it was a bomb or individual, I'd be ok with foil but not half a pizza. I need tobe able to carry it one handed between kids and being with someone who is at risk of falls. But my ranches we're over ¾fullthis time. Overall good but they charge almost $1 for 4oz container of ranch but you only get a half container, IF you'relucky.... This has happened Everytime. Read more
Best pizza Bombs around! Traveling thru town and we always try to make it a point to stop here for the DELICIOUS Pizza... bombs...(basically a larger calzone) comes with Marinara dip sauce and ranch for the breadstick type crust on the bomb. OurFavorite! Read more
Not much for atmosphere, but service is quick and friendly and the food is good. Their sandwiches have become our go to, they... put enough toppings on them where others skimp a bit. Beware for lunchtime rushes from the college, but great sandwichdestination! Read more