Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Plymouth, IN
Trying the Papa's Bowl, delicious. Enjoying the Chicken Alfredo Bowl..
I want to give them a five star as the ingredients are always fresh and delicious, but they can't seem to get my order right on... getting square cut. It's annoying to have to always have them check and find out it's not square cut. They do offer to make youanother pizza, but that takes an additional 10-15 minutes to get. If they can get the square cut orders right, I'll gladlyupdate to give stars! Update: Five stars as they have been diligent about checking for square cut. Always delicious, freshingredients. Our once or twice a month go to splurge. Read more
Very unprofessional, they wrote illicit words and images inside the box and the manager (Chris, Lexy) would not review the... footage to find out who did it, and refused to investigate any further.. Still trying to look someone for help with this issue Read more
Love the pizza. Would have rated 5 stars but they never cut in squares as I requested. Also, our last pizza was raw dough! We... had to reorder and wait another 40 minutes. Read more
Pizza was a little under baked, could be because the vegetables were in HUGE chunks and layered on and the pizza was unable to... bake correctly. Also forgot my sauce for my garlic knots so had to go back for that. Read more
My new favorite thin crust. I was worried it would be spicy because the box eluded to it. Some thin crust pizzas can shred the... inside of your mouth they are so thin and crisp. This one was just the right thickness and not too crisp. Great taste too with 2toppings, mushroom and sausage. Read more
Lived here over 20 years and I never had a problem ordering from this place. I especially like the pizza crust ends that act... like breadsticks. They even include the garlic dipping sauce to accommodate. Yummy. Read more
Counter dude seemed really confused, but food was ready, just as ordered, and delish