Reviews for Castaways in Plymouth, IN
The young man who seated was very nice with a great personality Hannah was our waitress she was very nice polite young lady with... excellent humor and personality.. definitely would give her 5 stars.. the food was awesome and didn't wait along time. Read more
Very friendly staff. Potluck dinner was fine, as was the chicken fajita wrap. Beer only in bottles. Pineapple mimosa was VERY... good! Read more
Well this has to be the worst service I've gotten at a sit down restaurant in a good 15 years. The host was nice but our server... really needs to find a new profession. Like really when a table asks for plenty of butter how is one container going to cut it?Checking on your tables. The server was even told each person who needs butter. When we told her we needed more she left andagain never brought extra butter. When she finally checked on us again we had to ask a third time for extra butter and finallyreceived it. No one has asked if any of us need refills on drinks and never offered to top off the coffee. The last time we werehere we had great service and when people told us we got lucky we didn't believe them. Now we know. We have been here multipletimes and even today it was not that busy. 9 out of 10 will not be returning here for a very long time until this issue isfixed. It's so sad because the food is very good too. Read more
Great host, server, and staff! Was very shocked and impressed that we could get soup AND salad AND dessert with the entrees! All... that food for very little price! So affordable! Portions were huge for the entree?s! Huge selection on the menu! Maddie wasgreat! Read more
Finally visited this little joint today to try out their breakfast that is served all day. I got their Garden Benedict on... sourdough with spinach, onion, and tomatoes topped with three perfectly poached eggs and a side of divine hollandaise saucealong with fruit. So good! Read more
I had the Texas Burger with an order of french fries and an order of onion rings with a bowl of taco soup. I could eat that taco... soup every single day and not get tired of it. It is good. The service is great. Always very kind. Read more
Personally I feel like this is the best diner in town. The other breakfast joints just slop everything on the plate, this place... actually cares what it looks and tastes like. Had lunch there for the first time and I was really impressed. Great familysetting. Will eat there many more times. Read more
My family's favorite spot but not mine food is ok and there was a huge mix up with salsa and chips and not having it taken off... the bill after it was asked to be cause they messed up. Not going back. Read more