Reviews for Jimmy John's in Plover, WI
I must say this was by far my worst experience. One sandwich was very slim on meats but it was cut in half w/xtra onions as... requested. The other sandwich was a bit more substantial but not cut in half n no xtra onions as requested. One place, twocompletely different results. Ive tried several times to get what I order, its hit or miss. I dont get it n very its verydisappointing. Will not try again. Food is not cheap n its like throwing money in the trash. You have been warned, someone inyour party wont get what they ordered. Read more
Went there today and ordered a 16" ultimate porker. Got back to work to eat it, to my disappointment it was turkey with bacon.... Every time, I have gone to this place they have messed my order up in some way. This visit definitely took the cake. Read more
Always amazing. Vito is a sandwich worthy of accolades!
Ordered 2 subs off door dash without realizing it was so close to closing time. Food was delivered and the subs were made... correctly and really good. Thank you! Read more
Food is okay. I never think there is much on the sandwiches especially veggie wise and the avocado spread is always very... minimal. Extra sauce is more money for an already expensive sandwich and meal and not worth it. The two of us got meals and itwas over $23. We won't do that again as it wasn't worth it to us for the food. We could have gone to a sit down restaurant forthose prices and will in the future. Read more
Stopped in for a quick lunch with my daughter. We both ordered Little John combos, her's was a ham and cheese, mine a turkey... tom. The cashier was kind enough to bring them to us because we sat down the second they were ready. We opened them and theywere both ham. I asked the cashier if I had actually ordered the turkey, he said yes, and I showed him the sandwich in case Iwas mistaken and it was turkey, he confirmed it was ham, and had the other teenage boy remake it. Up to this point, its not abig deal. When we had ordered I had forgotten to ask for no tomatoes, and opened the new sandwich to remove the tomatoes. That'swhen I found that I had been given just enough turkey to count as a garnish. Not enough to cover the bread lengthwise. If theywere less focused on being teenage boys joking around who happened to be at work, maybe they could have made an appropriatesandwich. Read more
Sandwiches were delicious but it was kind of awkward that it was drive through only. There were 5 of us with masks and we wanted... to place our orders individually and take them to go but were turned down at the door. Just a clunky experience. Nonethelessthe food was fresh and our order was fulfilled correctly. Read more
Terribly slow for being freaky fast.. store should close