Reviews for The Don Juan Mexican Restaurant in Pleasantville, NY
I ordered take out. My first call asked for info. I placed the order on the second call. When I came to pick it up, the... incompetent young employee said he thought I was joking because the order specified the way I asked that it be prepared. I hadto wait 30 minutes. The food is always good, but for take out, call back to see that the order was taken correctly Read more
Nice Mexican option in Pleasantville upper/mid-Westchester County. Highlight is an insane number of Tequila options. Favorite... beer is Modelo Negra (on tap!) Favorite Tequila is Hornitos Black Food hit the spot, healthy and hearty options Read more
Christian makes the best mojitos! Food is awesome. Service is great! Makes you feel very welcome. Like you are eating at home.... Owner Eduardo and wife are amazing! Read more
If we could give 4.5, we would. Food was great - steak tacos (Tacos Mexicanos) were some of the best cooked steak in a taco... ever. Flautas (chicken) were crispy and HUGE. The pico was chunky and not too wet, lots of flavor! Drinks - bartender waswonderful, but first round of drinks was wrong. Modelos were poured well, and kegs were fresh. Excited to go back! Read more
Food was decent, but the bartender was exceptional. He made the best drinks. He and his wife made sure we had the best... experience. He made us some custom drinks that were excellent. The vibe of the place was really good. Would definitely eat thereagain. Read more
Great portions, tasty food, and friendly staff(thanks Nancy). What else can you ask for, go there for all your Mexican food... cravings the portions are huge and the flavor of the food will make you go there more often than you expected. The drinks likethe margaritas with different flavors, great selection of mexican beers and if you like soccer(premier league+la ligaespañola..etc) they open at 10am so you can catch the european games..... The stake fajitas is one of my favorite dishes, butyou will like everything here. Read more
I came here for a dinner and it was a good experience. We ordered tacos and quesadilla and the food came out quickly, the... portions were decent and we had left overs. The raspberry margarita was also very delicious! It was my birthday and they made athing with ice cream and churros which was delicious. The prices are a bit much comparing to other Mexican places but I wouldprobably return. The guacamole was also very yummy! Read more
I don?t even think we can count how many times we have been to Don Juan. We probably go once a week. The staff are DELIGHTFUL.... HUGE shout out to Nancy who is probably the best server of all time and knows our order like the back of her hand. The food isalso great and reliable. They make Guacamole table side which is also cool. My only criticism is the disaster that was cinco demayo in 2022? they couldn?t hack it and all our favorite people were burned out and totally embarrassed. They don?t deserve lostpoints for this, but in hopes they don?t under perform next year, I hope this note is heard. Read more