Reviews for Marco Polo Pizzeria in Pleasantville, NJ

I ordered a Classic Chicken Caesar Salad and this is what I got! A ice cold salad with a little bit of chicken. Almost $14 for... this?. I was a regular here but unfortunately this will be my last time ordering from this place. Read more

I order online. Then I got the chicken quesadilla has extra ingredients. Some of this was slice fault not fully listings all the... ingredients. But on closer inspection there was no chicken and the tomatoes aren't slice well. And they didn't even try to makeit up or change it. Well not be ordering online and in person. Read more

I'm really picky about pizza and assorted Italian foods. Marco Polo was amazingly good. Sauce fantastic! Marinara... bellissimo!!! I ordered again and was just as delighted with everything. Thank you Marco Polo crew. You rock. Read more

My daughter usually gets the steak quesadilla and it's usually delicious. I had her get me one on Saturday and I was absolutely... disappointed. Idk what kind of meat they used but it definitely was not steak, the peppers and onions had no taste. I tried tomake it taste better with the sour cream to no avail, I then tried to add onion, tomatoes, mayonnaise, A1 sauce and salt and itwas still horrible. I finally gave up and just threw it away. I will never try another one. ???? Read more

Got a slice of pepperoni. I added garlic and onion powder when I reheated it at home, as I remember it being bland. Taste was... fair. Service was quick. 5/10 for taste and, thankfully being open longer than many other places in the area. Perhaps, I willtry a hoagie there some year. Thanks for being open longer than 10pm. Read more

I usually don’t order from this place but i wanted to give it a try. Never again. My cheesecake has mold on it ! I am so... disappointed because clearly customers service / costumer health is the least of this buisness priority. Read more

This food is phenomenal! Great reasonable prices and delicious tasty cuisine???? Got the onion rings again! They’re sooo good... esp wit the tartar sauce ???? Veggie quesadilla is rly good! First time trying the “baked penne Sicilian” and it tasteabsolutely amazing! ???? Love the ricotta cheese !! The tuna wrap was delicious tonight! They give you a lot of tuna for theprice.???? Read more

Best chicken salads in town to be honest for only $10.50. The salad includes plenty of chicken, fresh romaine salad, onion,... green pepper, black olives, croutons, tomatoes, Parmesan cheese, one boiled egg and also warm bread and butter. Read more