Reviews for Papa Luigi in Pitman, NJ
Best Spaghetti dinner I've ever had at a pizzeria!
Best cheesesteak in the area. Their pizza is also top notch. Consistency is a must in my book, and Papa Luigi's never misses the... mark. Read more
No gloves! I unfortunately had a pretty poor experience here today. I had already paid for my order and while waiting for it,... I watched horrified as a lady made my salad with no gloves- grabbing lettuce and tomato?s and just throwing it bare handed intothe bowl. She then proceeded to make a sub with no gloves (or mask, but whatever. I?m more concerned with the gloves). Ididn?t make a scene and accepted my food and then called on my home to let them know what I saw. I was then informed that they?never wear gloves? and that they ?don?t touch the food once it?s cooked.? I asked how this related to my salad and sub thatwere made with bare hands and are not cooked, but I was rudely informed that that was just how they did things. I don?t know,maybe I?m a little off here, but I didn?t think that was ? just how things are done? in the food business especially duringcovid times. Read more
6/26/21. So my fiancé and I moved to Pitman about a month ago. We enjoy eating out once or twice a week. We have found so many... places that we absolutely love but we continue to try new places and foods. We ordered from here for pick up. The food wasn?tready the time they said and then the total was incorrect from what I was told on the phone. We got a cheeseburger with megafries, Buffalo bites and a chicken cheesesteak hoagie. Everything was great except the burger. It really tasted like processedmeat and the bun was more of a sourdough taste. I wanted to do a 2 star but it deserved a 3 because the staff was very nice Read more
Great food. Best pizza in the area.
Chicken cheesesteak wrap with fries....delish!!! Kids loved the pepperoni slices and cheese fries!!! Bonus was running into an... old friend???? Read more
My wife and I order from here anytime we want take out. We've had pizza, subs, cheese steaks, fries, and whenever my parents... visit they usually get a big serving of lasagna! It's our go to! Not overly priced and run by a good group of people. Thank youfor great pizza! Read more
Since moving to Gloucester county, this is one of the best pizza places I've found.